{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "display_policy": "all_display_eligible_evidence_is_public_and_reviewable_by_annotation", "country": { "iso3": "SGP", "name": "Singapore", "aliases": [ "Singapore" ], "type": "country", "who_region": "WPR", "who_region_source": "WPR", "wb_region": "East Asia & Pacific", "income_group": "high", "first_year": 2000, "last_core_year": 2023 }, "build": { "version": "2026-08-23+6c22928b", "built_at": "2026-08-23T06:47:49Z" }, "summary": { "direct_typed_sources": 0, "direct_typed_claims": 0, "direct_typed_relationships": 0, "direct_typed_decision_rights": 0, "candidate_sources": 1, "candidate_facts": 0, "exact_contexts": 0, "source_linked_analytical_mappings": 10, "source_linked_analytical_object_rows": 28, "all_material_records": 27, "library_document_candidates": 3, "candidate_queue_records": 23, "current_public_projection_records": 1 }, "availability": [ { "domain": "actors", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 15, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "government_responsibilities", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "ownership", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 4, "exact_context_count": 2, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "decision_rights", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 9, "exact_context_count": 6, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "autonomy", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 7, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "primary_care", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 20, "exact_context_count": 9, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "hospital_organization", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 6, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "referral_design", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "observed_referral", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "networks", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 19, "exact_context_count": 10, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "facility_data", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 4, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "utilization", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 6, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "patient_flows", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 6, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "governance", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 23, "exact_context_count": 11, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "market_structure", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "reform_history", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "authoritative_review", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 21, "exact_context_count": 11, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." } ], "direct_typed_objects": { "sources": [], "claims": [], "actors": [], "relationships": [], "decision_rights": [], "provider_organizations": [], "autonomy": [], "accountability": [], "referrals": [], "patient_flows": [], "networks": [], "integration": [], "reforms": [] }, "source_linked_analytical_mappings": [ { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:actors-functions:stewardship-and-delivery", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "target_view": "functions", "target_slot": "stewardship-primary-care-and-hospital-delivery", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "WHO system case study and official programme source", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site" ], "typed_fields": { "stewardship": "WHO identifies Ministry of Health leadership in the PHC case study.", "delivery": "The case study describes mixed public-private primary care.", "boundary": "Neither source establishes current provider-level ownership, budgets or performance." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "sgp:moh", "label": "Ministry of Health", "family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:e09762b6841aa4327c3d1d2f" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:e09762b6841aa4327c3d1d2f" }, { "node_id": "sgp:primary-care", "label": "Primary-care providers", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:09d216c487720bc7ec2d7160" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:09d216c487720bc7ec2d7160" }, { "node_id": "sgp:hospitals", "label": "Hospitals", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:e0a214c4aff9c0d4144aa166" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:e0a214c4aff9c0d4144aa166" }, { "node_id": "sgp:community", "label": "Community organizations", "family": "community", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:37a80da8b7ad81172342e026" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:37a80da8b7ad81172342e026" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "sgp:moh", "target_node_id": "sgp:primary-care", "relationship": "leads stated primary-care policy direction", "relationship_family": "governance", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:03c9f704907e10b7a407f74e" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:03c9f704907e10b7a407f74e" }, { "source_node_id": "sgp:primary-care", "target_node_id": "sgp:community", "relationship": "is intended to strengthen links with community organizations", "relationship_family": "network", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:ff664c09d2dcc7c17ea606aa" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:ff664c09d2dcc7c17ea606aa" } ] }, "title": "National stewardship and mixed primary-care delivery", "statement": "WHO's 2023 case study reports Ministry of Health leadership and mixed public-private primary care. Healthier SG is represented as a stated policy direction, not proof of uniform current delivery.", "citation": "WHO 2023; Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG.", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": "WHO Overview; official programme homepage.", "period": "2020 to 2023 source context", "territory": "Singapore", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "networks", "governance", "market_structure", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Geneva: WHO; 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" }, { "title": "Healthier SG", "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health. Healthier SG. https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Healthier SG", "source_word_anchor": "Healthier SG is Singapore's national initiative", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:4f7a76d56c5cbdfbb7796e94", "display-claim:e09762b6841aa4327c3d1d2f", "display-claim:09d216c487720bc7ec2d7160", "display-claim:e0a214c4aff9c0d4144aa166", "display-claim:37a80da8b7ad81172342e026", "display-claim:03c9f704907e10b7a407f74e", "display-claim:ff664c09d2dcc7c17ea606aa" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:4f7a76d56c5cbdfbb7796e94", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:autonomy:provider-accountability-boundary", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "target_view": "autonomy", "target_slot": "reported-network-participation-and-unknown-provider-discretion", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "PCN capacity study and integrated-care maturity assessment", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-capacity-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "network_participation": "Studies report Primary Care Network capacity building and integrated-care assessment.", "autonomy": "They do not establish a nationwide autonomy score or contractual authority for providers.", "accountability": "Assessment and outcome-harvesting findings are not accountability audits." }, "analytical_objects": { "autonomy_cells": [ { "dimension": "Operations", "provider_group": "Primary care", "authority_label": "Network participation and care processes are discussed in study settings", "counterpart": "National autonomy and accountability arrangements are not established by these studies.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:cee3a96042d87a30ef9dd796" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:cee3a96042d87a30ef9dd796" } ], "decision_cells": [ { "decision_id": "sgp:decision:pcn", "decision_label": "Primary Care Network care-process participation", "actor_label": "Primary Care Networks", "actor_family": "provider", "role": "Study setting for reported capacity-building change", "constraint": "Not a national provider-autonomy measure.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:4c1e836c9ec77d7c3a2250d6" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:4c1e836c9ec77d7c3a2250d6" } ] }, "title": "Network studies do not establish nationwide autonomy", "statement": "Research describes network-level change and integrated-care assessment, but does not establish universal primary-care or hospital financial, workforce or service-mix autonomy.", "citation": "Tan et al. 2023; Wee et al. 2024.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "locator": "Both articles: Abstract, Methods and Results.", "period": "Studies published 2023 and 2024", "territory": "Singapore study settings", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "networks", "governance", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Evaluating the Effects of Capacity Building Initiatives and Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Evaluating the Effects of Capacity Building Initiatives and Primary Care Networks in Singapore: Outcome Harvesting of System Changes to Chronic Disease Care Delivery. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2023;20:2192. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "eb4edd5d4cecd2b456e39826adf221dd8403606ae75c2929fbfa969cd327bd76", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-capacity-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" }, { "title": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool", "citation": "Wee SL, et al. Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool. International Journal of Integrated Care. 2024;24. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "1ab1f928e650d87134f5c591b26f139bc9fa29164b046ef37e744f681bba0d07", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "eb4edd5d4cecd2b456e39826adf221dd8403606ae75c2929fbfa969cd327bd76", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:df62056879c3ec2bd22b4336", "display-claim:cee3a96042d87a30ef9dd796", "display-claim:4c1e836c9ec77d7c3a2250d6" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:df62056879c3ec2bd22b4336", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:decisions:policy-and-programme-design", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "target_view": "decisions", "target_slot": "national-policy-and-primary-care-programme-design", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "official programme and WHO case study", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023" ], "typed_fields": { "policy_design": "The Ministry of Health is the named national programme authority.", "provider_decision_boundary": "Sources do not establish individual-provider contracting, staffing or financial discretion.", "accountability_boundary": "No audited accountability metric is supplied." }, "analytical_objects": { "decision_cells": [ { "decision_id": "sgp:decision:programme", "decision_label": "National Healthier SG programme design", "actor_label": "Ministry of Health", "actor_family": "national", "role": "Named official programme authority", "constraint": "Programme source does not demonstrate implementation completeness.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:7d0e1f1359bde5d8e140515e" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:7d0e1f1359bde5d8e140515e" }, { "decision_id": "sgp:decision:care-linkage", "decision_label": "Stated health-service and community linkage direction", "actor_label": "Ministry of Health", "actor_family": "national", "role": "Policy direction reported by WHO", "constraint": "Not evidence of completed linkage for every provider.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:a437dead2c4b290f297fb25e" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:a437dead2c4b290f297fb25e" } ] }, "title": "Programme authority is national; provider discretion is not established", "statement": "The available official sources identify national programme direction. They do not support a claim about current decision rights of every primary-care provider or hospital.", "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG; WHO 2023.", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "locator": "Official programme homepage; WHO Overview.", "period": "2022 policy context and 2023 report", "territory": "Singapore", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "governance", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Healthier SG", "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health. Healthier SG. https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Healthier SG", "source_word_anchor": "Healthier SG is Singapore's national initiative", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" }, { "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Geneva: WHO; 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:d1de671dcdde7665d1cfb5dc", "display-claim:7d0e1f1359bde5d8e140515e", "display-claim:a437dead2c4b290f297fb25e" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:d1de671dcdde7665d1cfb5dc", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:delivery:hospital-to-community-programme", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "delivery", "target_slot": "hospital-to-community-integrated-care-programme", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "process evaluation of a hospital-to-community strategy", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:integrated-care-process-2020", "country-improvement-source:SGP:hospital-at-home-readiness-2025" ], "typed_fields": { "delivery_model": "A 2020 study evaluated implementation fidelity of a hospital-to-community strategy.", "hospital_at_home": "A 2025 qualitative study reports readiness views for scale-up.", "boundary": "Neither establishes national availability or delivery performance." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "Hospital-to-community strategy", "observation": "Implementation fidelity was evaluated in the study programme.", "scope": "Programme evaluation, not all Singapore hospitals.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:b59fdfefb7340321cc338338" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:b59fdfefb7340321cc338338" }, { "label": "Hospital-at-home readiness", "observation": "Partners reported readiness and policy needs.", "scope": "Qualitative readiness evidence, not utilization.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:467f88a6ab136a0cda588ae2" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:467f88a6ab136a0cda588ae2" } ] }, "title": "Hospital-to-community evidence is programme-bounded", "statement": "Published work evaluates a hospital-to-community programme and reports hospital-at-home readiness perspectives. It does not establish national delivery capacity, utilization or outcomes.", "citation": "Yong et al. 2020; Tan et al. 2025.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/", "locator": "Process-evaluation Abstract, Methods and Discussion; hospital-at-home Abstract and Results.", "period": "Studies published 2020 and 2025", "territory": "Singapore study and interview settings", "evidence_mode_candidate": "observed", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "hospital_organization", "networks", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "citation": "Yong C, et al. Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity. BMC Health Services Research. 2020;20:452. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Discussion" ], "source_word_anchor": "process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "114ad28bed4a399d2f87640ace6ae35d93e76cac08198e92918e3b7b1b3596d2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:integrated-care-process-2020", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669" }, { "title": "Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness", "citation": "Tan WS, et al. Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness, and policy and implementation strategies essential to support scale-up. PLOS One. 2025. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "state of readiness and policy", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "fba2fe9a6fd1becabdb1b8e2355d17f3d7774a1eb70aa3e8d9c37b1f56c2a636", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:hospital-at-home-readiness-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "114ad28bed4a399d2f87640ace6ae35d93e76cac08198e92918e3b7b1b3596d2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:64d71ba28e5f3e74cc96271c", "display-claim:b59fdfefb7340321cc338338", "display-claim:467f88a6ab136a0cda588ae2" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:64d71ba28e5f3e74cc96271c", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:delivery:pcn-diabetes-care", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "delivery", "target_slot": "participating-primary-care-network-diabetes-model", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "two mixed-methods PCN diabetes studies", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-patient-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "care_model": "Studies examine diabetes care in participating Primary Care Networks.", "patient_experience": "One study reports patient perspectives.", "boundary": "These are not national measures of care quality or service coverage." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "PCN diabetes care", "observation": "Integrated patient-centred diabetes care was studied in participating networks.", "scope": "Study model and enrolled population only.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:882da19b06c98d9856451ebd" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:882da19b06c98d9856451ebd" } ] }, "title": "Diabetes-care observations apply to participating networks", "statement": "The cited studies provide observed and experiential evidence for defined Primary Care Network diabetes models. They do not demonstrate delivery performance throughout the national system.", "citation": "Lim et al. 2023; Tan et al. 2024.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "locator": "Both articles: Abstract, Methods and Results.", "period": "Studies published 2023 and 2024", "territory": "Singapore participating Primary Care Networks", "evidence_mode_candidate": "observed", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "networks", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study", "citation": "Lim J, et al. Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study. BMC Health Services Research. 2023;23:1445. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "d4e96cc0769a2c93d59b62e7cf2ba155ac20ab808b9395759543332b9cfc4e55", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-patient-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c" }, { "title": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks: a mixed-methods study. BMJ Open. 2024. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "2b71dbe8ac243ff33c715704bc6c6997bcea9da2add7de304b1615fed79cf47f", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "d4e96cc0769a2c93d59b62e7cf2ba155ac20ab808b9395759543332b9cfc4e55", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:4e58f944f172c2b5637eec39", "display-claim:882da19b06c98d9856451ebd" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:4e58f944f172c2b5637eec39", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:public-private:mixed-primary-care-and-network-branch", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "target_view": "public-private", "target_slot": "mixed-primary-care-and-network-linkages", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "WHO PHC case study and PCN research", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-capacity-2023" ], "typed_fields": { "market_structure": "WHO describes mixed public-private primary care.", "network_branch": "PCN research concerns participating networks.", "boundary": "Evidence does not quantify current contracting or market shares." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "sgp:public-primary", "label": "Public primary care", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:b6f824f16413bcc313a7327d" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:b6f824f16413bcc313a7327d" }, { "node_id": "sgp:private-primary", "label": "Private primary care", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:dac53259e7fefcc77f685dfa" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:dac53259e7fefcc77f685dfa" }, { "node_id": "sgp:pcn", "label": "Primary Care Networks", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:491567e9c5ec93614d0be382" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:491567e9c5ec93614d0be382" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "sgp:pcn", "target_node_id": "sgp:private-primary", "relationship": "studied as a primary-care network setting", "relationship_family": "network", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:79bfaccfd197abb0d29feef7" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:79bfaccfd197abb0d29feef7" } ] }, "title": "Primary care is described as mixed, with bounded network evidence", "statement": "WHO reports mixed public-private primary care and research describes participating Primary Care Networks. Neither source supports a present-tense national market-share or contracting claim.", "citation": "WHO 2023; Tan et al. 2023.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "locator": "WHO Overview; PCN article Abstract and Methods.", "period": "WHO report 2023; PCN study 2023", "territory": "Singapore", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "ownership", "primary_care", "networks", "governance", "market_structure", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Geneva: WHO; 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" }, { "title": "Evaluating the Effects of Capacity Building Initiatives and Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Evaluating the Effects of Capacity Building Initiatives and Primary Care Networks in Singapore: Outcome Harvesting of System Changes to Chronic Disease Care Delivery. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2023;20:2192. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "eb4edd5d4cecd2b456e39826adf221dd8403606ae75c2929fbfa969cd327bd76", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-capacity-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:289bc4bde102d529e8113fb9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:6556f2d96ae58488c2898054" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:e887ce0608b7599d5df3c3b2", "display-claim:b6f824f16413bcc313a7327d", "display-claim:dac53259e7fefcc77f685dfa", "display-claim:491567e9c5ec93614d0be382", "display-claim:79bfaccfd197abb0d29feef7" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:e887ce0608b7599d5df3c3b2", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:referrals:formal-linkage-and-bounded-observation", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "referrals", "target_slot": "formal-linkage-direction-and-study-bounded-pathways", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "WHO policy case study and PCN diabetes studies", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-patient-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "formal_design": "WHO reports a policy direction to enhance links among services and community organizations.", "observed_layer": "PCN studies observe defined diabetes-care settings.", "counter_referral": "No source establishes national counter-referral completion.", "boundary": "No national bypassing or referral-completion rate is inferred." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "sgp:patient", "label": "Study participants and patients", "family": "community", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:2e3f3b71a07cabecacf8bccd" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:2e3f3b71a07cabecacf8bccd" }, { "node_id": "sgp:pcn-primary", "label": "Participating PCN primary care", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:101ea692386d9265c233c1ba" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:101ea692386d9265c233c1ba" }, { "node_id": "sgp:hospital-care", "label": "Hospital care", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:185939e4c3cc5cb0aeeed014" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:185939e4c3cc5cb0aeeed014" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "sgp:pcn-primary", "target_node_id": "sgp:hospital-care", "relationship": "integrated-care pathway evidence is limited to study settings", "relationship_family": "referral", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:151d925d7fd7c85493b45d74" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:151d925d7fd7c85493b45d74" } ] }, "title": "Referral evidence does not support a national completion claim", "statement": "Policy sources state linkage intentions and PCN studies provide bounded care-pathway evidence. The pack contains no national referral completion, counter-referral or bypassing estimate.", "citation": "WHO 2023; Lim et al. 2023; Tan et al. 2024.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/", "locator": "WHO Overview; PCN study Abstract, Methods and Results.", "period": "2023 to 2024 publications", "territory": "Singapore; PCN studies are limited to their sampled settings", "evidence_mode_candidate": "observed", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "patient_flows", "governance", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Geneva: WHO; 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" }, { "title": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study", "citation": "Lim J, et al. Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study. BMC Health Services Research. 2023;23:1445. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "d4e96cc0769a2c93d59b62e7cf2ba155ac20ab808b9395759543332b9cfc4e55", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-patient-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c" }, { "title": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks: a mixed-methods study. BMJ Open. 2024. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "2b71dbe8ac243ff33c715704bc6c6997bcea9da2add7de304b1615fed79cf47f", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:102a55d7659953c72cf8c38a", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:151d0e5dd9dc84c0a5e0af5c", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c200ed5953a1f3cac7a953a6", "display-claim:2e3f3b71a07cabecacf8bccd", "display-claim:101ea692386d9265c233c1ba", "display-claim:185939e4c3cc5cb0aeeed014", "display-claim:151d925d7fd7c85493b45d74" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c200ed5953a1f3cac7a953a6", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:reforms:formal-intent-versus-observed-implementation", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "target_view": "reforms", "target_slot": "formal-policy-reported-assessment-and-observed-study-boundaries", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "official programme, reform commentary, maturity assessment and outcome studies", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-commentary-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024", "country-improvement-source:SGP:hospital-at-home-readiness-2025" ], "typed_fields": { "formal": "The official source is used for stated programme design.", "reported": "Commentary and maturity assessment report reform framing and assessment findings.", "observed": "PCN study observations are limited to participating model settings.", "readiness": "Hospital-at-home interviews report readiness views, not service availability." }, "analytical_objects": { "reform_events": [ { "event_id": "sgp:boundary:formal", "label": "Official programme design", "year": 2023, "status": "Formal source, not implementation proof.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:997aba398f5267ec01c79c39" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:997aba398f5267ec01c79c39" }, { "event_id": "sgp:boundary:assessment", "label": "Integrated-care maturity assessment", "year": 2024, "status": "Reported assessment finding, not performance audit.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:26ef0b8dd668aee4c620cf3d" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:26ef0b8dd668aee4c620cf3d" }, { "event_id": "sgp:boundary:readiness", "label": "Hospital-at-home readiness interviews", "year": 2025, "status": "Reported readiness views, not national service coverage.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:f0d9ce0c3e9fc3cc73215a87" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:f0d9ce0c3e9fc3cc73215a87" } ] }, "title": "Formal design, reported assessment and observed studies remain distinct", "statement": "Singapore sources in this pack span formal programme design, reported maturity assessment and observed study models. They are deliberately not combined into claims about current national practice or performance.", "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG; Tan et al. 2023; Wee et al. 2024; Tan et al. 2024; Tan et al. 2025.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "locator": "Official programme homepage; cited articles' Abstract, Methods and Results.", "period": "2023 to 2025", "territory": "Singapore; observed studies are setting-specific", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Healthier SG", "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health. Healthier SG. https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Healthier SG", "source_word_anchor": "Healthier SG is Singapore's national initiative", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" }, { "title": "Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond. Lancet Regional Health - Western Pacific. 2023;38:100893. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Introduction", "Healthier SG" ], "source_word_anchor": "for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "8671f6457990377e4192ae742331a036b5c1496edcac98c9954a2af79c7fc271", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-commentary-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa" }, { "title": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool", "citation": "Wee SL, et al. Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool. International Journal of Integrated Care. 2024;24. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "1ab1f928e650d87134f5c591b26f139bc9fa29164b046ef37e744f681bba0d07", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" }, { "title": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks: a mixed-methods study. BMJ Open. 2024. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "2b71dbe8ac243ff33c715704bc6c6997bcea9da2add7de304b1615fed79cf47f", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c" }, { "title": "Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness", "citation": "Tan WS, et al. Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness, and policy and implementation strategies essential to support scale-up. PLOS One. 2025. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "state of readiness and policy", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "fba2fe9a6fd1becabdb1b8e2355d17f3d7774a1eb70aa3e8d9c37b1f56c2a636", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:hospital-at-home-readiness-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "display-source:SGP:e3f66366149a5fd89cc1d566", "display-source:SGP:3656874047208a2f0f2b0af5" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22", "display-source-version:1ebefa6a5a0e66247267e33c", "display-source-version:7bce19c6675516cd500ee770" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:14053dc49a21abfc00e646ac", "display-claim:997aba398f5267ec01c79c39", "display-claim:26ef0b8dd668aee4c620cf3d", "display-claim:f0d9ce0c3e9fc3cc73215a87" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:14053dc49a21abfc00e646ac", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:reforms:healthier-sg-and-care-shift-timeline", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "target_view": "reforms", "target_slot": "care-shift-pcn-and-healthier-sg-timeline", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "WHO case study, official programme site and reform literature", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-commentary-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:integrated-care-process-2020" ], "typed_fields": { "2020": "A hospital-to-community integrated-care strategy was evaluated in a published process study.", "2022": "WHO identifies the September 2022 Healthier SG White Paper context.", "2023": "Official and commentary sources describe Healthier SG policy direction.", "boundary": "This timeline records policy and study events, not national causal effects." }, "analytical_objects": { "reform_events": [ { "event_id": "sgp:reform:2020-care-shift", "label": "Hospital-to-community strategy process evaluation", "year": 2020, "status": "Programme-level implementation evidence.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:29e55ef033a6150b9f1edb8a" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:29e55ef033a6150b9f1edb8a" }, { "event_id": "sgp:reform:2022-healthier-sg-white-paper", "label": "Healthier SG White Paper context", "year": 2022, "status": "Policy direction reported by WHO.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c614445f704262c3337766f2" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c614445f704262c3337766f2" }, { "event_id": "sgp:reform:2023-programme", "label": "Healthier SG official programme presentation", "year": 2023, "status": "Formal programme source; implementation and outcomes are not inferred.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:026ed92c05ddb7cfbc81477c" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:026ed92c05ddb7cfbc81477c" } ] }, "title": "Reform sources show policy direction and bounded implementation studies", "statement": "The evidence pack records a care-shift evaluation and the Healthier SG policy chronology. It does not attribute national outcomes to either event.", "citation": "WHO 2023; Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG; Tan et al. 2023; Yong et al. 2020.", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": "WHO Overview; official programme homepage; commentary Introduction; process-study Abstract.", "period": "2020 to 2023", "territory": "Singapore", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "networks", "governance", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Geneva: WHO; 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1" }, { "title": "Healthier SG", "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health. Healthier SG. https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "locator": { "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "heading": "Healthier SG", "source_word_anchor": "Healthier SG is Singapore's national initiative", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec" }, { "title": "Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond. Lancet Regional Health - Western Pacific. 2023;38:100893. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Introduction", "Healthier SG" ], "source_word_anchor": "for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "8671f6457990377e4192ae742331a036b5c1496edcac98c9954a2af79c7fc271", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-commentary-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa" }, { "title": "Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "citation": "Yong C, et al. Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity. BMC Health Services Research. 2020;20:452. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Discussion" ], "source_word_anchor": "process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "114ad28bed4a399d2f87640ace6ae35d93e76cac08198e92918e3b7b1b3596d2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:integrated-care-process-2020", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:05850f1cbc2c76c1409ace4f", "display-source:SGP:385d2a79e5d2cffed5795058", "display-source:SGP:dc0b30c17f4badf54e1bfee6", "display-source:SGP:767ccde9e947d09599ba1829" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:ebbda380df5afb1b3c71e5b1", "display-source-version:ac4cd74aa71eaa7734e673ec", "display-source-version:b89a451cde3e59f7987629fa", "display-source-version:9f95ed96cb23933d06d3d669" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:bfbba7a8dbd103f539bf412c", "display-claim:29e55ef033a6150b9f1edb8a", "display-claim:c614445f704262c3337766f2", "display-claim:026ed92c05ddb7cfbc81477c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:bfbba7a8dbd103f539bf412c", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:relationships:high-risk-utilizers-and-network-evidence", "country_id": "SGP", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "target_view": "referrals", "target_slot": "observed-high-risk-utilization-and-network-boundaries", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "high-risk-utilizer cohort and integrated-care assessment", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:high-risk-utilizer-cohort-2019", "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "observed_utilization": "A cohort reports heterogeneous high-risk-utilizer patterns.", "network_assessment": "Integrated-care maturity is assessed using a structured tool.", "boundary": "Neither source measures all national patient flows or referral outcomes." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "High-risk-utilizer cohort", "observation": "Longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns were reported for a defined cohort.", "scope": "Not a national referral-performance measure.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:523b5929e0d82294f03ccbbb" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:32c8e2f10d4cf49ac2de7192", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:88de12973efb4bd7099c38e0", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:523b5929e0d82294f03ccbbb" } ] }, "title": "Utilization and maturity sources answer different questions", "statement": "The high-risk cohort observes defined utilization patterns while the maturity study reports a structured integrated-care assessment. These sources should not be combined into a national referral-performance claim.", "citation": "Low et al. 2019; Wee et al. 2024.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6894210/", "locator": "Cohort Abstract, Methods and Results; maturity-study Abstract, Methods and Results.", "period": "Studies published 2019 and 2024", "territory": "Singapore; defined cohort and assessment respondents", "evidence_mode_candidate": "observed", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "observed_referral", "utilization", "patient_flows", "networks", "governance", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "The heterogeneous health state profiles of high-risk healthcare utilizers and their longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns", "citation": "Low LL, et al. The heterogeneous health state profiles of high-risk healthcare utilizers and their longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns. BMC Health Services Research. 2019;19:931. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6894210/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6894210/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "b9b5095fce4404763d8d60de724f979bbf154368de4e450c443510cc1a83d7a7", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:high-risk-utilizer-cohort-2019", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:32c8e2f10d4cf49ac2de7192", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:88de12973efb4bd7099c38e0" }, { "title": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool", "citation": "Wee SL, et al. Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool. International Journal of Integrated Care. 2024;24. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "sections": [ "Abstract", "Methods", "Results" ], "source_word_anchor": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "1ab1f928e650d87134f5c591b26f139bc9fa29164b046ef37e744f681bba0d07", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "b9b5095fce4404763d8d60de724f979bbf154368de4e450c443510cc1a83d7a7", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SGP:32c8e2f10d4cf49ac2de7192", "display-source:SGP:aed6e1ecaaac56fc5083c61e" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:88de12973efb4bd7099c38e0", "display-source-version:fe64083ed576c80e91814b22" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:4557d0df042664159ea57352", "display-claim:523b5929e0d82294f03ccbbb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:4557d0df042664159ea57352", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" } ], "displayed_evidence": { "candidate_sources": [ { "candidate_source_id": "candidate-source:SGP:ce8471825bdfb5f930dc", "evidence_layer": "candidate_source_metadata", "evidence_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_type": "candidate source metadata", "display_eligible": true, "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "citation_string": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "citation_status": "supplied", "citation_provenance": "source metadata", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "publication_year": 2023, "source_families": [ "WHO_AHPSR" ], "channels": [ "targeted_official" ], "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "url_verification_status": "verified", "source_version": { "file_sha256": null, "text_sha256": null, "response_sha256": "bc522d232fdb6ede40018440b9eb1b52642e9ed53aced8a5836dd7bcff425d85", "page_count": null }, "locator": null, "display_status": "shown_in_full", "review_channel": "text_anchored_annotation", "verification_requirements": [] } ], "candidate_facts": [], "exact_contexts": [] }, "evidence_scorecard": { "country_id": "SGP", "audit_passed": true, "preparation_stage": "direct_typed_mapping", "preparation_stage_label": "Explicit analytical mappings", "scores": { "analytical_mapping_groups": { "denominator": 5, "numerator": 5, "score": 100, "unit": "explicit analytical object groups" }, "controlled_domain_leads": { "denominator": 17, "numerator": 17, "score": 100, "unit": "controlled domains with displayed candidate leads" }, "material_locator_coverage": { "denominator": 27, "numerator": 27, "score": 100, "unit": "material records with an exact locator" }, "material_url_coverage": { "denominator": 27, "numerator": 27, "score": 100, "unit": "material records with at least one public URL" }, "material_version_coverage": { "denominator": 27, "numerator": 27, "score": 100, "unit": "material records with an immutable source version" }, "source_layer_presence": { "denominator": 3, "numerator": 3, "score": 100, "unit": "displayed candidate-source layers" } }, "represented_domain_ids": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "missing_domain_ids": [], "direct_typed_domain_ids": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "priority_actions": [ { "action_id": "annotate-country-synthesis", "detail": "All six preparation dimensions meet the target. Every source-linked finding and supporting material remains open for correction, qualification, and additional evidence through annotations.", "label": "Review and annotate the country synthesis" } ], "review_ready_material_ids": [ "material:ec5057681547f576a2edaca1", "material:c6ac55a8f62e332e481bfbf9", "material:b1f1532ed58c8b3d0e7815c7", "material:a5cdadbb099718364745f9f7", "material:a2dada003577e323cf8fa408" ], "full_scorecard_url": "https://wb-works.site/tools/health-organization/data/evidence-scorecards.json" }, "materials": [ { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Availability or relevance uncertain", "downloaded": false, "extracted": false, "text_pages": null, "text_words": null }, "citation": "Urban age (5,4) : Urban age - living less in Asian cities. 1998. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "AUS", "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "unknown", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 8, "source_word_anchor": "even in matters of health Instead of visiting trysbde Now tnou sanos", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:54aab6a42ab98c5db8b25665", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "1998-05-31", "publication_year": 1998, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 40, "response_sha256": "9a295718a3c5dd230f3fea9e2fd2f8437f287ff6b22ba2071b8c1be0c5074088" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "population_group:rural_remote" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Urban age (5,4) : Urban age - living less in Asian cities", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/262531468119356591/pdf/multi-page.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/262531468119356591" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/262531468119356591/text/multi-page.txt" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "two mixed-methods PCN diabetes studies", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:delivery:pcn-diabetes-care", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-patient-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "participating-primary-care-network-diabetes-model", "target_view": "delivery", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "These are not national measures of care quality or service coverage.", "care_model": "Studies examine diabetes care in participating Primary Care Networks.", "patient_experience": "One study reports patient perspectives." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Lim et al. 2023; Tan et al. 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Both articles: Abstract, Methods and Results." }, "material_id": "material:e159121f1af6531dc4a7a80e", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Studies published 2023 and 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "d4e96cc0769a2c93d59b62e7cf2ba155ac20ab808b9395759543332b9cfc4e55" }, "statement": "The cited studies provide observed and experiential evidence for defined Primary Care Network diabetes models. They do not demonstrate delivery performance throughout the national system.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore participating Primary Care Networks", "title": "Diabetes-care observations apply to participating networks", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "official programme, reform commentary, maturity assessment and outcome studies", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:reforms:formal-intent-versus-observed-implementation", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-commentary-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024", "country-improvement-source:SGP:hospital-at-home-readiness-2025" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "formal-policy-reported-assessment-and-observed-study-boundaries", "target_view": "reforms", "typed_fields": { "formal": "The official source is used for stated programme design.", "observed": "PCN study observations are limited to participating model settings.", "readiness": "Hospital-at-home interviews report readiness views, not service availability.", "reported": "Commentary and maturity assessment report reform framing and assessment findings." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG; Tan et al. 2023; Wee et al. 2024; Tan et al. 2024; Tan et al. 2025.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Official programme homepage; cited articles' Abstract, Methods and Results." }, "material_id": "material:b5d15ddc40f54ec56a08b891", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2023 to 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae" }, "statement": "Singapore sources in this pack span formal programme design, reported maturity assessment and observed study models. They are deliberately not combined into claims about current national practice or performance.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; observed studies are setting-specific", "title": "Formal design, reported assessment and observed studies remain distinct", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Healthier SG", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "process evaluation of a hospital-to-community strategy", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:delivery:hospital-to-community-programme", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:integrated-care-process-2020", "country-improvement-source:SGP:hospital-at-home-readiness-2025" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "hospital-to-community-integrated-care-programme", "target_view": "delivery", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "Neither establishes national availability or delivery performance.", "delivery_model": "A 2020 study evaluated implementation fidelity of a hospital-to-community strategy.", "hospital_at_home": "A 2025 qualitative study reports readiness views for scale-up." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Yong et al. 2020; Tan et al. 2025.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Process-evaluation Abstract, Methods and Discussion; hospital-at-home Abstract and Results." }, "material_id": "material:ab9f63226bebb1d61ef7cc57", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Studies published 2020 and 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "114ad28bed4a399d2f87640ace6ae35d93e76cac08198e92918e3b7b1b3596d2" }, "statement": "Published work evaluates a hospital-to-community programme and reports hospital-at-home readiness perspectives. It does not establish national delivery capacity, utilization or outcomes.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore study and interview settings", "title": "Hospital-to-community evidence is programme-bounded", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "WHO system case study and official programme source", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:actors-functions:stewardship-and-delivery", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "stewardship-primary-care-and-hospital-delivery", "target_view": "functions", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "Neither source establishes current provider-level ownership, budgets or performance.", "delivery": "The case study describes mixed public-private primary care.", "stewardship": "WHO identifies Ministry of Health leadership in the PHC case study." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO 2023; Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "WHO Overview; official programme homepage." }, "material_id": "material:25f014a8cb7034f7c584d899", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2020 to 2023 source context", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff" }, "statement": "WHO's 2023 case study reports Ministry of Health leadership and mixed public-private primary care. Healthier SG is represented as a stated policy direction, not proof of uniform current delivery.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore", "title": "National stewardship and mixed primary-care delivery", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Healthier SG", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "PCN capacity study and integrated-care maturity assessment", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:autonomy:provider-accountability-boundary", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-capacity-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "reported-network-participation-and-unknown-provider-discretion", "target_view": "autonomy", "typed_fields": { "accountability": "Assessment and outcome-harvesting findings are not accountability audits.", "autonomy": "They do not establish a nationwide autonomy score or contractual authority for providers.", "network_participation": "Studies report Primary Care Network capacity building and integrated-care assessment." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Tan et al. 2023; Wee et al. 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "networks", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Both articles: Abstract, Methods and Results." }, "material_id": "material:3b17044f3354590bb72b00a6", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Studies published 2023 and 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "eb4edd5d4cecd2b456e39826adf221dd8403606ae75c2929fbfa969cd327bd76" }, "statement": "Research describes network-level change and integrated-care assessment, but does not establish universal primary-care or hospital financial, workforce or service-mix autonomy.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore study settings", "title": "Network studies do not establish nationwide autonomy", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "WHO PHC case study and PCN research", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:public-private:mixed-primary-care-and-network-branch", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-capacity-2023" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "mixed-primary-care-and-network-linkages", "target_view": "public-private", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "Evidence does not quantify current contracting or market shares.", "market_structure": "WHO describes mixed public-private primary care.", "network_branch": "PCN research concerns participating networks." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO 2023; Tan et al. 2023.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "governance", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "WHO Overview; PCN article Abstract and Methods." }, "material_id": "material:c379f5c7cd2f41dc5830dfc4", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "WHO report 2023; PCN study 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff" }, "statement": "WHO reports mixed public-private primary care and research describes participating Primary Care Networks. Neither source supports a present-tense national market-share or contracting claim.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore", "title": "Primary care is described as mixed, with bounded network evidence", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "official programme and WHO case study", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:decisions:policy-and-programme-design", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "national-policy-and-primary-care-programme-design", "target_view": "decisions", "typed_fields": { "accountability_boundary": "No audited accountability metric is supplied.", "policy_design": "The Ministry of Health is the named national programme authority.", "provider_decision_boundary": "Sources do not establish individual-provider contracting, staffing or financial discretion." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG; WHO 2023.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Official programme homepage; WHO Overview." }, "material_id": "material:3d5d457072f9cec34b164314", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2022 policy context and 2023 report", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae" }, "statement": "The available official sources identify national programme direction. They do not support a claim about current decision rights of every primary-care provider or hospital.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore", "title": "Programme authority is national; provider discretion is not established", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "WHO policy case study and PCN diabetes studies", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:referrals:formal-linkage-and-bounded-observation", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-patient-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:pcn-diabetes-integrated-care-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "formal-linkage-direction-and-study-bounded-pathways", "target_view": "referrals", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "No national bypassing or referral-completion rate is inferred.", "counter_referral": "No source establishes national counter-referral completion.", "formal_design": "WHO reports a policy direction to enhance links among services and community organizations.", "observed_layer": "PCN studies observe defined diabetes-care settings." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO 2023; Lim et al. 2023; Tan et al. 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "WHO Overview; PCN study Abstract, Methods and Results." }, "material_id": "material:184f3cba5422ee9b62577213", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2023 to 2024 publications", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff" }, "statement": "Policy sources state linkage intentions and PCN studies provide bounded care-pathway evidence. The pack contains no national referral completion, counter-referral or bypassing estimate.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; PCN studies are limited to their sampled settings", "title": "Referral evidence does not support a national completion claim", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "WHO case study, official programme site and reform literature", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:reforms:healthier-sg-and-care-shift-timeline", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:who-phc-case-study-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-official-site", "country-improvement-source:SGP:healthier-sg-commentary-2023", "country-improvement-source:SGP:integrated-care-process-2020" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "care-shift-pcn-and-healthier-sg-timeline", "target_view": "reforms", "typed_fields": { "2020": "A hospital-to-community integrated-care strategy was evaluated in a published process study.", "2022": "WHO identifies the September 2022 Healthier SG White Paper context.", "2023": "Official and commentary sources describe Healthier SG policy direction.", "boundary": "This timeline records policy and study events, not national causal effects." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO 2023; Singapore Ministry of Health, Healthier SG; Tan et al. 2023; Yong et al. 2020.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "WHO Overview; official programme homepage; commentary Introduction; process-study Abstract." }, "material_id": "material:eac3558dc7af687836eef28d", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2020 to 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff" }, "statement": "The evidence pack records a care-shift evaluation and the Healthier SG policy chronology. It does not attribute national outcomes to either event.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore", "title": "Reform sources show policy direction and bounded implementation studies", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Healthier SG", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "high-risk-utilizer cohort and integrated-care assessment", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SGP:relationships:high-risk-utilizers-and-network-evidence", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SGP:high-risk-utilizer-cohort-2019", "country-improvement-source:SGP:scirocco-integrated-care-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "observed-high-risk-utilization-and-network-boundaries", "target_view": "referrals", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "Neither source measures all national patient flows or referral outcomes.", "network_assessment": "Integrated-care maturity is assessed using a structured tool.", "observed_utilization": "A cohort reports heterogeneous high-risk-utilizer patterns." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Low et al. 2019; Wee et al. 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "governance", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Cohort Abstract, Methods and Results; maturity-study Abstract, Methods and Results." }, "material_id": "material:f479d44ee8b71627f0d6f833", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Studies published 2019 and 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "b9b5095fce4404763d8d60de724f979bbf154368de4e450c443510cc1a83d7a7" }, "statement": "The high-risk cohort observes defined utilization patterns while the maturity study reports a structured integrated-care assessment. These sources should not be combined into a national referral-performance claim.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; defined cohort and assessment respondents", "title": "Utilization and maturity sources answer different questions", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6894210/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Evaluating the Effects of Capacity Building Initiatives and Primary Care Networks in Singapore: Outcome Harvesting of System Changes to Chronic Disease Care Delivery. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2023;20:2192. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "facility_data", "governance", "market_structure", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "institution": "International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:37f17f7de33ed7bb7c3d0f6f", "notes": [ "Report stakeholder-derived changes as reported, not proven national effects." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Study published 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "eb4edd5d4cecd2b456e39826adf221dd8403606ae75c2929fbfa969cd327bd76" }, "statement": "The study reports stakeholder-identified system changes associated with capacity-building initiatives and Primary Care Networks for chronic-disease care. Outcome harvesting is not a national causal-effect estimate.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; Primary Care Networks and chronic-disease care initiatives", "title": "Evaluating the Effects of Capacity Building Initiatives and Primary Care Networks in Singapore", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9915000/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Singapore Ministry of Health. Healthier SG. https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "networks", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "Healthier SG is Singapore's national initiative", "institution": "Singapore Ministry of Health", "locator": { "heading": "Healthier SG", "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "Healthier SG is Singapore's national initiative", "source_word_count": 7 }, "material_id": "material:139016dec3a80b8372025d13", "notes": [ "Use this as formal programme evidence only.", "Do not infer current practice, participation or national performance from the webpage." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Official programme website retrieved 2026-08-22; policy launch context stated by source", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "3705a1a23c746730915ace2e51d01e8ed0a84b65d55b077f500b00ea0b781eae" }, "statement": "The official programme site presents Healthier SG as a Ministry of Health policy programme. It is used only for the programme's stated policy design, not to establish implementation completeness or patient outcomes.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; Healthier SG policy programme", "title": "Healthier SG", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.healthiersg.gov.sg/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond. Lancet Regional Health - Western Pacific. 2023;38:100893. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "market_structure", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "institution": "Lancet Regional Health - Western Pacific / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:ec5057681547f576a2edaca1", "notes": [ "Separate stated reform intent from observed results." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Published 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "8671f6457990377e4192ae742331a036b5c1496edcac98c9954a2af79c7fc271" }, "statement": "The commentary describes Healthier SG's intended preventive and primary-care transformation. It is explanatory reform literature, not a measurement of completed implementation or national outcomes.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; Healthier SG reform commentary", "title": "Healthier SG: for a healthier Singapore and beyond", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10485661/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Tan WS, et al. Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness, and policy and implementation strategies essential to support scale-up. PLOS One. 2025. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "governance", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "patient_flows", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "state of readiness and policy", "institution": "PLOS One / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "state of readiness and policy", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:2676bca03cba9f7082020e85", "notes": [ "Keep readiness evidence distinct from delivery evidence." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Qualitative study published 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2025, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "fba2fe9a6fd1becabdb1b8e2355d17f3d7774a1eb70aa3e8d9c37b1f56c2a636" }, "statement": "The qualitative study reports partners' views of readiness and policy needs for hospital-at-home scale-up. It does not establish national availability, utilization, referral performance or outcomes.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; health-system-partner interviews on hospital-at-home scale-up", "title": "Hospital-at-home care in Singapore: a qualitative exploration of health system partners' state of readiness", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12129231/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Tan KB, et al. Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks: a mixed-methods study. BMJ Open. 2024. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "governance", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes", "institution": "BMJ Open / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes", "source_word_count": 7 }, "material_id": "material:a2dada003577e323cf8fa408", "notes": [ "Do not extrapolate study-model findings to all primary care." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Study published 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "2b71dbe8ac243ff33c715704bc6c6997bcea9da2add7de304b1615fed79cf47f" }, "statement": "This mixed-methods study evaluates integrated patient-centred diabetes care in participating Primary Care Networks. Its observations are limited to the study model and enrolled population.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; participating Primary Care Networks and type 2 diabetes care", "title": "Integrated patient-centred care for type 2 diabetes in Singapore Primary Care Networks", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11191786/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Wee SL, et al. Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool. International Journal of Integrated Care. 2024;24. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care", "institution": "International Journal of Integrated Care / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:7b3f3fcd68245e2517c778b3", "notes": [ "Describe maturity results as assessment findings, not national performance grades." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Assessment published 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "1ab1f928e650d87134f5c591b26f139bc9fa29164b046ef37e744f681bba0d07" }, "statement": "The article reports a structured assessment of integrated-care maturity in Singapore. Its assessment method and respondents do not constitute an audited measure of all provider performance or patient flows.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; structured integrated-care maturity assessment", "title": "Measuring the Maturity of Integrated Care in Singapore with the SCIROCCO Exchange Tool", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11451543/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Lim J, et al. Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study. BMC Health Services Research. 2023;23:1445. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "governance", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care", "institution": "BMC Health Services Research / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:5a0468f0089a71b902719e9a", "notes": [ "Do not generalize participant experience to all Singapore primary care." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Study published 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "d4e96cc0769a2c93d59b62e7cf2ba155ac20ab808b9395759543332b9cfc4e55" }, "statement": "The mixed-methods study reports patient perspectives on diabetes care within sampled Primary Care Networks. It provides bounded experiential evidence, not a national measure of continuity, referral completion or quality.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; sampled people with diabetes in Primary Care Networks", "title": "Patient perspectives of diabetes care in primary care networks in Singapore: a mixed-methods study", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10734143/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Yong C, et al. Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity. BMC Health Services Research. 2020;20:452. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": "process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "institution": "BMC Health Services Research / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:c6ac55a8f62e332e481bfbf9", "notes": [ "Keep findings at programme level.", "Do not generalize fidelity findings to all hospitals or primary-care providers." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Implementation evaluation published 2020", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2020, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "114ad28bed4a399d2f87640ace6ae35d93e76cac08198e92918e3b7b1b3596d2" }, "statement": "This process evaluation examines implementation fidelity for a hospital-to-community integrated-care strategy. Its findings are programme-specific and do not measure national referral completion or system-wide integration.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; evaluated hospital-to-community programme settings", "title": "Shifting care from hospital to community, a strategy to integrate care in Singapore: process evaluation of implementation fidelity", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7245814/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "The Commonwealth Fund. Singapore. International Health Care System Profiles. May 2026. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/2026_Country-Profiles_Singapore.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "facility_data", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "Public health care providers are organized into three location-based integrated care clusters", "institution": "The Commonwealth Fund", "locator": { "heading": "The Role of Government", "locator_type": "pdf_page_text_anchor", "physical_pdf_page": 5, "source_word_anchor": "Public health care providers are organized into three location-based integrated care clusters", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:2f4642f4945c54429d791efb", "notes": [ "Treat this as a dated secondary system profile.", "Do not infer current service performance, nationwide referral completion or causal effects." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "International Health Care System Profile published May 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "grey_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 20, "response_sha256": "f80dfe2611c6bdaa106d30a94eb986fa9d213b252f31aa658cbbbc06ce58d242" }, "statement": "This independent system profile describes the public provider-cluster arrangement and broader health-system organization. It is secondary descriptive evidence, not evidence of current operational performance, population outcomes or causal effects.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore national health system", "title": "Singapore", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/2026_Country-Profiles_Singapore.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Geneva: WHO; 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "institution": "World Health Organization", "locator": { "heading": "Overview", "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "enhance links between health services and community organizations", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:b1f1532ed58c8b3d0e7815c7", "notes": [ "Treat the case study as a dated system description.", "Do not infer current enrolment, access, quality or national performance." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "COVID-19 context January 2020 to December 2022; report published 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cc3554bcd5595d26535b0ae33d60fbb7caa2c94736f79207867a48f10ecf20ff" }, "statement": "WHO describes a mixed public-private primary-care system and the September 2022 Healthier SG policy direction, including proposed stronger links among health services, community organizations, information technology and primary-care financing.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore national primary-health-care system", "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Low LL, et al. The heterogeneous health state profiles of high-risk healthcare utilizers and their longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns. BMC Health Services Research. 2019;19:931. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6894210/", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "governance", "hospital_organization", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": "longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns", "institution": "BMC Health Services Research / PubMed Central", "locator": { "locator_type": "article_sections", "source_word_anchor": "longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:a5cdadbb099718364745f9f7", "notes": [ "Retain the high-risk-cohort boundary." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Longitudinal study published 2019", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2019, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "b9b5095fce4404763d8d60de724f979bbf154368de4e450c443510cc1a83d7a7" }, "statement": "This cohort study reports heterogeneous utilization, readmission and mortality patterns among defined high-risk utilizers. It does not establish population-wide hospital performance or the effect of a national reform.", "tags": [], "territory": "Singapore; study cohort of high-risk healthcare utilizers", "title": "The heterogeneous health state profiles of high-risk healthcare utilizers and their longitudinal hospital readmission and mortality patterns", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6894210/" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "candidate source metadata", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "heading": "Overview", "html_text_block": 5, "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "financing models alongside good governance led by the Ministry of Health MoH", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "candidate-source:SGP:ce8471825bdfb5f930dc", "notes": [ "Public source projection retained as a distinct stage record.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the locator-gap traceability audit." ], "origin": "current-public-source-projection", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "displayed_source_projection", "record_kind_label": "Displayed source projection", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_locator_gap_acquisition": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata", "official" ], "source_system": "WHO_AHPSR", "source_version": { "response_sha256": "bc522d232fdb6ede40018440b9eb1b52642e9ed53aced8a5836dd7bcff425d85" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "targeted_official" ], "territory": null, "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Availability or relevance uncertain", "downloaded": false, "extracted": false, "text_pages": null, "text_words": null }, "citation": "Comparing Individual Retirement Accounts in Asia : Singapore, Thailand, Hong Kong and PRC (China). 2006. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 3, "physical_pdf_page": 8, "source_word_anchor": "allow members to buy health insurance pay medical expenses and use as", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:32e97a1f30a2f13b981063c0", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2006-09-01", "publication_year": 2006, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 102, "response_sha256": "9956c625cbc821623c153c642401a8f56a71dfdcc4c716e920ef0176d4a7f268" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Comparing Individual Retirement Accounts in Asia : Singapore, Thailand, Hong Kong and PRC (China)", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/922941468101940975/text/37432rev.txt" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/922941468101940975" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/922941468101940975/pdf/37432rev.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Availability or relevance uncertain", "downloaded": false, "extracted": false, "text_pages": null, "text_words": null }, "citation": "Impact 3 (2) : corruption. 1999. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "health_financing", "pooling_insurance" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "unknown", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 11, "source_word_anchor": "payment of Alcysius month-long hospital stay They care organization when they did", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:178db2eae89b36fb5cf46847", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "1999-03-31", "publication_year": 1999, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 28, "response_sha256": "4fde89bb5f1e1a4877271af49b6322d0b77e56890849bd288808c86ce2cc394f" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "service_area:cross_cutting", "who_building_block:health_financing" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Impact 3 (2) : corruption", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/327131468035952343/pdf/multi0page.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/327131468035952343/text/multi0page.txt" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/327131468035952343" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "heading": "Overview", "html_text_block": 5, "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "financing models alongside good governance led by the Ministry of Health MoH", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:3b2deb887badb2b6e477af58", "notes": [ "Verify the exact bibliographic citation against the original source.", "Confirm that the document applies to the named country and intended territorial scope.", "Confirm document type, issuing institution, authority, and claim-specific suitability.", "Retrieve and hash the exact source version when it is not already verified.", "Check publication date, effective period, currency, and supersession risk.", "Confirm only domains directly supported by the reviewed source.", "Add substantive feedback directly through the text-anchored annotation layer.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the locator-gap traceability audit." ], "origin": "global-source-triage-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "source_triage_record", "record_kind_label": "Source Triage Record", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_locator_gap_acquisition": true, "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review" }, "source_layers": [ "WHO_AHPSR" ], "source_system": "WHO_AHPSR", "source_version": { "response_sha256": "bc522d232fdb6ede40018440b9eb1b52642e9ed53aced8a5836dd7bcff425d85" }, "statement": null, "tags": [], "territory": null, "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "World Health Organization. Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. 2023. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793", "country_ids": [ "SGP" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "primary_health_care_country_report", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Health Organization", "locator": { "heading": "Overview", "html_text_block": 5, "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "financing models alongside good governance led by the Ministry of Health MoH", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:e974316cf949c449ade09898", "notes": [ "Authoritative official source page or publication exposes country-specific health-system organization, governance, delivery, or primary-care context.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the locator-gap traceability audit.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the locator-gap traceability audit." ], "origin": "targeted-gap-source-leads", "period": null, "publication_date": "2023-08-31", "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "targeted_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Targeted Source Lead", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_locator_gap_acquisition": true, "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "unreviewed", "source_version_linked_from_locator_gap_acquisition": true, "status": "candidate" }, "source_layers": [], "source_system": "WHO_AHPSR", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "93c3a6ce5fa2546b942810bd7282a3a04cf28e37bed70dee6ced7636ad48e103" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "health_system_design", "health_system_organization", "service_delivery" ], "territory": null, "title": "Singapore: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "stable_url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240079793" } ] } ] }