{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "display_policy": "all_display_eligible_evidence_is_public_and_reviewable_by_annotation", "country": { "iso3": "SAU", "name": "Saudi Arabia", "aliases": [ "Saudi Arabia" ], "type": "country", "who_region": "EMR", "who_region_source": "EMR", "wb_region": "Middle East, North Africa, Afghanistan & Pakistan", "income_group": "high", "first_year": 2000, "last_core_year": 2023 }, "build": { "version": "2026-08-23+6c22928b", "built_at": "2026-08-23T06:47:49Z" }, "summary": { "direct_typed_sources": 0, "direct_typed_claims": 0, "direct_typed_relationships": 0, "direct_typed_decision_rights": 0, "candidate_sources": 3, "candidate_facts": 0, "exact_contexts": 0, "source_linked_analytical_mappings": 10, "source_linked_analytical_object_rows": 29, "all_material_records": 42, "library_document_candidates": 14, "candidate_queue_records": 25, "current_public_projection_records": 3 }, "availability": [ { "domain": "actors", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 14, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "government_responsibilities", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 13, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "ownership", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 8, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "decision_rights", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "autonomy", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "primary_care", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 25, "exact_context_count": 9, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "hospital_organization", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 13, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "referral_design", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 12, "exact_context_count": 7, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "observed_referral", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 3, "exact_context_count": 1, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "networks", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 13, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "facility_data", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "utilization", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 8, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "patient_flows", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "governance", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 15, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "market_structure", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 9, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "reform_history", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 8, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "authoritative_review", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." } ], "direct_typed_objects": { "sources": [], "claims": [], "actors": [], "relationships": [], "decision_rights": [], "provider_organizations": [], "autonomy": [], "accountability": [], "referrals": [], "patient_flows": [], "networks": [], "integration": [], "reforms": [] }, "source_linked_analytical_mappings": [ { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:actors-functions:dated-system-review-context", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "target_view": "functions", "target_slot": "dated-system-review-context", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "2011 peer-reviewed health-system overview", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:health-system-overview-2011" ], "typed_fields": { "reported": "The 2011 review synthesizes the health-system organization of its assessment period.", "boundary": "It is not a current legal allocation of Ministry, cluster, insurer, regulator, or provider functions." }, "analytical_objects": { "function_assignments": [ { "actor_label": "National health-system governance", "function_label": "Dated organization context", "role": "Reported in 2011 review", "actor_family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:8f8cffda6bacc7b88ccda815" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:3429726afeed683669c1f795" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:b45ce665d4970c7e2a6a72eb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:8f8cffda6bacc7b88ccda815" } ] }, "title": "Historical system review supplies dated context only", "statement": "The review is retained as dated organizational context and is not used to infer current roles.", "citation": "Almalki, FitzGerald and Clark. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. 2011;17(10):784-793.", "url": "https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-17/volume-17-issue-10/article-11.html", "locator": "Article title and review page; source dated 2011.", "period": "2011 review", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "governance", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview", "citation": "Almalki M, FitzGerald G, Clark M. Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. 2011;17(10):784-793. https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-17/volume-17-issue-10/article-11.html", "url": "https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-17/volume-17-issue-10/article-11.html", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading", "section": "Article title and review", "source_word_anchor": "Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "ddec30a0634f0981b104beb94ab31f59a34a4a2a8b4e1fc222e3c60feb1c5124", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:health-system-overview-2011", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:3429726afeed683669c1f795", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:b45ce665d4970c7e2a6a72eb" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "ddec30a0634f0981b104beb94ab31f59a34a4a2a8b4e1fc222e3c60feb1c5124", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:3429726afeed683669c1f795" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:b45ce665d4970c7e2a6a72eb" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:5f3d2e50703af9369381f20e", "display-claim:8f8cffda6bacc7b88ccda815" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:5f3d2e50703af9369381f20e", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:actors-functions:formal-stewardship-and-clusters", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "target_view": "functions", "target_slot": "formal-stewardship-and-cluster-description", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Ministry corporatization overview and July 2024 Ministry announcement", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-branches-news-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "formal": "The Ministry describes organizing and supervising roles and describes Health Holding Company-supervised clusters as delivery arrangements.", "reported": "The July 2024 announcement reports regional directorates being transformed into Ministry branches.", "boundary": "Neither source supplies a complete current authority matrix or independently verifies operating practice." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "sau:moh", "label": "Ministry of Health", "family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:59b6b5efac7eba482c2515f2" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:59b6b5efac7eba482c2515f2" }, { "node_id": "sau:health-clusters", "label": "Health clusters", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:6abd21ad558ec1acb6c9c74f" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:6abd21ad558ec1acb6c9c74f" }, { "node_id": "sau:health-holding-company", "label": "Health Holding Company", "family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:b6f61e7ecd53c68aa7eae8da" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:b6f61e7ecd53c68aa7eae8da" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "sau:moh", "target_node_id": "sau:health-clusters", "relationship": "is described as organizing and supervising sector while clusters provide services", "relationship_family": "governance", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:1b0e5576a9f8c6d39c3dae4e" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:1b0e5576a9f8c6d39c3dae4e" }, { "source_node_id": "sau:health-holding-company", "target_node_id": "sau:health-clusters", "relationship": "is described as supervising regional business units for clusters", "relationship_family": "governance", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:3c9bc0c4cc9728cab7e2a50b" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:3c9bc0c4cc9728cab7e2a50b" } ], "function_assignments": [ { "actor_label": "Ministry of Health", "function_label": "Sector organization and supervision", "role": "Ministry-described institutional role", "actor_family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:21af954bc21c1d1d57e3f198" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:21af954bc21c1d1d57e3f198" }, { "actor_label": "Health clusters", "function_label": "Integrated service provision", "role": "Ministry-described delivery arrangement", "actor_family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:ab82fac7001a64e9e9965f4f" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:ab82fac7001a64e9e9965f4f" } ] }, "title": "Ministry stewardship and cluster roles are described, not independently verified", "statement": "Ministry sources describe a stewardship and delivery separation involving Ministry supervision and health clusters. This is formal or reported institutional material, not a complete current function map.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities, retrieved 2026; Ministry of Health news release, 18 July 2024.", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "locator": "Corporatization overview, Overview; 18 July 2024 news release, Page Content.", "period": "2024 announcement and 2026 retrieved Ministry description", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "governance", "reform_history" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "free the health clusters from centralized decision-making", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20" }, { "title": "Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA. 18 July 2024. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Page Content", "source_word_anchor": "separating organizational and supervisory roles", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "7647dee35a53afbff87c77ff4e0c578a2353897e2bec51f25e30e54361314472", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-branches-news-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:a280e663dbfe99691830b005", "display-claim:59b6b5efac7eba482c2515f2", "display-claim:6abd21ad558ec1acb6c9c74f", "display-claim:b6f61e7ecd53c68aa7eae8da", "display-claim:1b0e5576a9f8c6d39c3dae4e", "display-claim:3c9bc0c4cc9728cab7e2a50b", "display-claim:21af954bc21c1d1d57e3f198", "display-claim:ab82fac7001a64e9e9965f4f" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:a280e663dbfe99691830b005", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:decision-autonomy:accountability-boundary", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "target_view": "autonomy", "target_slot": "autonomy-and-accountability-boundary", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Ministry corporatization and transformation-strategy descriptions", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-healthcare-transformation-strategy-2026" ], "typed_fields": { "formal": "The Ministry describes reduced centralized decision-making and a strategy toward value-based services.", "accountability_boundary": "The displayed material does not specify a current enforceable accountability mechanism or provider autonomy by financial, workforce, procurement, operational and clinical domain.", "boundary": "Policy description is not evidence of actual autonomy or accountable-care results." }, "analytical_objects": { "decision_cells": [ { "decision_id": "sau:provider-autonomy-accountability", "decision_label": "Provider autonomy and accountability", "actor_label": "Health clusters and providers", "actor_family": "provider", "role": "Not rated from displayed sources", "constraint": "No current domain-specific autonomy and accountability matrix is supplied.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:efb03e093a858ecb74c18400" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:54860093acb9c4fa77c8bb46" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:fec401e3ba7bd45e9d3d0663" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:efb03e093a858ecb74c18400" } ] }, "title": "Autonomy and accountability cannot be rated from the displayed sources", "statement": "The sources state institutional aims but do not document current autonomy or accountability arrangements by decision domain.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Corporatization overview; Healthcare Transformation Strategy, retrieved 2026.", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx", "locator": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy page; Corporatization overview, Overview.", "period": "Ministry pages retrieved 2026", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "free the health clusters from centralized decision-making", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20" }, { "title": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Healthcare Transformation Strategy. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "source_word_anchor": "roadmap towards providing value-based healthcare services", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "63cd1e5d1b18b0d5880684089d40633b570af2171c11c58d16437865550e9af4", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-healthcare-transformation-strategy-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:54860093acb9c4fa77c8bb46", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:fec401e3ba7bd45e9d3d0663" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:54860093acb9c4fa77c8bb46" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:fec401e3ba7bd45e9d3d0663" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:0fb229af4d1024798f5bfdc7", "display-claim:efb03e093a858ecb74c18400" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:0fb229af4d1024798f5bfdc7", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:decision-autonomy:cluster-decision-description", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "target_view": "decisions", "target_slot": "described-cluster-operational-decisions", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Ministry corporatization overview and 2018 delivery plan", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018" ], "typed_fields": { "formal": "The sources describe intended cluster-related decisions on employment, maintenance and transfers.", "decision_boundary": "They do not establish which decisions are currently delegated, by cluster, for budgets, procurement, capital, service mix or clinical governance.", "boundary": "No autonomy score is inferred." }, "analytical_objects": { "decision_cells": [ { "decision_id": "sau:cluster-employment-maintenance-transfer", "decision_label": "Employment, maintenance and selected transfer decisions", "actor_label": "Health clusters", "actor_family": "provider", "role": "Described decision space", "constraint": "No source validates current delegation or scope by individual cluster.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:6b3e9f539593d914dbbc4760" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:6b3e9f539593d914dbbc4760" }, { "decision_id": "sau:cluster-budget-procurement", "decision_label": "Budget, procurement and capital authority", "actor_label": "Health clusters", "actor_family": "provider", "role": "Not classified", "constraint": "Displayed sources do not provide a current provider-by-function authority table.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c8ac14817e2b00765776f924" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c8ac14817e2b00765776f924" } ] }, "title": "Some cluster decisions are described; the wider authority matrix is unclassified", "statement": "Ministry sources describe selected cluster operational decisions but do not support a current comprehensive decision-rights matrix.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Corporatization overview, retrieved 2026; Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan, 2018.", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "locator": "Corporatization overview, Overview; HSTP Delivery Plan, Institutional transformation of healthcare facilities.", "period": "2018 plan and 2026 retrieved description", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "decision_rights", "autonomy", "governance", "actors", "government_responsibilities" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "free the health clusters from centralized decision-making", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20" }, { "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan. 2018. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "pages": [ 48, 49 ], "sections": [ "Institutional transformation of healthcare facilities" ], "source_word_anchor": "separate the provision of health services from the Ministry", "source_word_count": 10 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:a7ac45754c39a912e4701852", "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:a83a498272a69ad781deee20", "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:5638cc6183b5ab3f27ab01f8", "display-claim:6b3e9f539593d914dbbc4760", "display-claim:c8ac14817e2b00765776f924" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:5638cc6183b5ab3f27ab01f8", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:delivery-referrals:observed-ehalati-case", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "referrals", "target_slot": "observed-nine-centre-ehalati-referrals", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Retrospective e-referral case study", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:ehalati-case-study-2022" ], "typed_fields": { "observed": "The study records 52,143 sequential referrals from nine designated PHC centres to one receiving hospital between 2019 and 2021.", "scope_boundary": "The study's facilities, districts and time window cannot establish a national referral-completion, bypass or patient-choice rate." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "sau:study-phc", "label": "Nine designated primary-health-care centres", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:4a1ce1ab740ca0904fccfc20" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:4a1ce1ab740ca0904fccfc20" }, { "node_id": "sau:study-receiving-hospital", "label": "Receiving hospital in e-referral case study", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:9dc9f3614688e6a1d4ed58c6" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:9dc9f3614688e6a1d4ed58c6" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "sau:study-phc", "target_node_id": "sau:study-receiving-hospital", "relationship": "52,143 sequential referrals observed, 2019-2021", "relationship_family": "referral", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:582e618cfcb8e9fa3515978d" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:582e618cfcb8e9fa3515978d" } ], "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "Ehalati case-study referrals", "observation": "52,143 observed sequential referrals", "scope": "Nine centres, one receiving hospital, 2019-2021.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:d7ca3f5a1eace946228f3291" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:d7ca3f5a1eace946228f3291" } ] }, "title": "Observed e-referrals are site- and time-bounded", "statement": "A case study observed referrals from nine centres to one hospital during 2019-2021. It is empirical local evidence, not national referral performance.", "citation": "Alabbasi, Kruger and Tennant. Clinics and Practice. 2022;12(3):364-377.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/", "locator": "Materials and Methods; Results.", "period": "1 January 2019 to 30 December 2021", "territory": "Nine designated PHC centres covering 34 districts and one receiving hospital, Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "observed", "verification_source_layer": "research_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study", "citation": "Alabbasi KH, Kruger E, Tennant M. Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study. Clinics and Practice. 2022;12(3):364-377. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Materials and Methods; Results", "source_word_anchor": "52,143 referrals from the 9 designated PHC centres", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "97f53501b1878990383df69245e34247c61f0c2b0dd174889db8b20b3d8aa589", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:ehalati-case-study-2022", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "97f53501b1878990383df69245e34247c61f0c2b0dd174889db8b20b3d8aa589", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:3ce5573b32a4a37fcd2105bb", "display-claim:4a1ce1ab740ca0904fccfc20", "display-claim:9dc9f3614688e6a1d4ed58c6", "display-claim:582e618cfcb8e9fa3515978d", "display-claim:d7ca3f5a1eace946228f3291" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:3ce5573b32a4a37fcd2105bb", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:delivery-referrals:reported-care-path-delivery", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "delivery", "target_slot": "reported-2023-care-path-context", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Ministry Modern Healthcare Model page and HSTP Annual Report 2023", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-modern-healthcare-model-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:hstp-annual-report-2023" ], "typed_fields": { "reported": "The Ministry reports 2023 cluster care-path implementation and the program reports 2023 activity and indicators.", "boundary": "These sources do not provide a common national delivery denominator, completed pathway rate, or causal performance estimate." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "Care paths through primary care, general hospitals, specialized hospitals and medical cities", "observation": "Reported Ministry model and 2023 program context", "scope": "No observed national completion or utilization denominator is supplied.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:ca3190350e45ba52abfe20c2" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:ed4777cd897d4409328101ed", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:7842049150dbad78ee1684b6", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:ca3190350e45ba52abfe20c2" } ] }, "title": "Reported care-path activity is not a national patient-flow measure", "statement": "The sources describe care pathways and 2023 program activity, without validating current nationwide pathway use or completion.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Modern Healthcare Model, retrieved 2026; Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023, published 2024.", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/about/pages/definition-modern-healthcare-model.aspx", "locator": "Modern Healthcare Model, Healthcare Pathways; HSTP Annual Report 2023, Foreword and Executive summary.", "period": "Reported 2023 implementation and annual-report period", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Modern Healthcare Model", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Modern Healthcare Model. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/about/pages/definition-modern-healthcare-model.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/about/pages/definition-modern-healthcare-model.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Healthcare Pathways", "source_word_anchor": "health clusters implemented medical care paths", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "7a1867bbb9e2c768e6e3625d6476de791acf247d3ec29d6cf7608411d1b38888", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-modern-healthcare-model-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:ed4777cd897d4409328101ed", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:7842049150dbad78ee1684b6" }, { "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023", "citation": "Health Sector Transformation Program. Annual Report 2023. 2024. https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf", "url": "https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "pages": [ 5, 6 ], "sections": [ "Foreword", "Executive summary" ], "source_word_anchor": "annual report on the healthcare sector's achievements", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "5ed695f5db8a5f71c5d5280fa3919ab88f4ee9b4f10f50d1421f6ba65d4c57cc", "response_sha256": "5ed695f5db8a5f71c5d5280fa3919ab88f4ee9b4f10f50d1421f6ba65d4c57cc", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:hstp-annual-report-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "7a1867bbb9e2c768e6e3625d6476de791acf247d3ec29d6cf7608411d1b38888", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:ed4777cd897d4409328101ed", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:7842049150dbad78ee1684b6", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:5395981bbbadebc3fa8f4615", "display-claim:ca3190350e45ba52abfe20c2" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:5395981bbbadebc3fa8f4615", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:delivery-referrals:reviewed-phc-boundary", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "delivery", "target_slot": "reviewed-phc-improvement-and-privatisation-boundary", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "2024 systematic review of 18 studies", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:phc-privatisation-systematic-review-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "reported": "The review reports cross-study primary-care evidence on infrastructure, workforce, policy and reform context.", "boundary": "Heterogeneous study evidence does not yield a current national capacity, ownership, utilization or referral-performance estimate." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "Primary-health-care improvement and privatization evidence", "observation": "Systematic review of 18 studies", "scope": "Study-specific settings and dates; no pooled national delivery denominator.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:97cb2f2280dc156ca164e11f" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:f0bbef6864931ce77ebafd1b" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:5f66178353d2832c3ff01e29" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:97cb2f2280dc156ca164e11f" } ] }, "title": "Review evidence cannot become a current national delivery estimate", "statement": "The systematic review adds bounded primary-care context but no current national delivery or market-share value.", "citation": "Albaher and Alqurashi. Cureus. 2024;16(12):e76357.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "locator": "Abstract and Methods.", "period": "Review published 2024; included studies have individual dates", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, included-study settings", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "referral_design", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "ownership", "market_structure", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Primary Healthcare Centre Improvement and Privatisation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: A Systematic Review", "citation": "Albaher Z, Alqurashi H. Primary Healthcare Centre Improvement and Privatisation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: A Systematic Review. Cureus. 2024;16(12):e76357. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Abstract", "source_word_anchor": "substantial gaps in critical domains", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "bee11643dc11f9f2db83c5f2c670400ac39de71c83e8d956632b625de05d0455", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:phc-privatisation-systematic-review-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:f0bbef6864931ce77ebafd1b", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:5f66178353d2832c3ff01e29" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "bee11643dc11f9f2db83c5f2c670400ac39de71c83e8d956632b625de05d0455", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:f0bbef6864931ce77ebafd1b" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:5f66178353d2832c3ff01e29" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:d40d2a89fb3552af9efa2361", "display-claim:97cb2f2280dc156ca164e11f" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:d40d2a89fb3552af9efa2361", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:relationships-networks:formal-ehalati-route", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "target_view": "referrals", "target_slot": "formal-ehalati-level-and-regional-route", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Ministry Ehalati FAQ", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-ehalati-faq-2026" ], "typed_fields": { "formal_referral_design": "The FAQ describes first-to-second and second-to-third level referral routes, plus directorate-level coordination for referral outside a region.", "boundary": "The design does not measure completed transitions, counter-referrals, bypassing or patient choice." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "sau:phc", "label": "First-level health centres", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c1e7d45642f37d9ab0c180bf" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c1e7d45642f37d9ab0c180bf" }, { "node_id": "sau:second-level", "label": "Second-level hospitals", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:ddae3383e5f00ffa04ed1c0e" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:ddae3383e5f00ffa04ed1c0e" }, { "node_id": "sau:third-level", "label": "Third-level hospitals", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:3d0225f8a264a33abb76e723" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:3d0225f8a264a33abb76e723" }, { "node_id": "sau:directorate-coordination", "label": "Directorate treatment-eligibility and medical-coordination departments", "family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:3e61b4df79dc0c132d16cfcb" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:3e61b4df79dc0c132d16cfcb" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "sau:phc", "target_node_id": "sau:second-level", "relationship": "formal referral route described", "relationship_family": "referral", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:6a086bafd5110c9a65228766" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:6a086bafd5110c9a65228766" }, { "source_node_id": "sau:second-level", "target_node_id": "sau:third-level", "relationship": "formal referral route described", "relationship_family": "referral", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:84005cdc20175c53c2c6b8c6" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:84005cdc20175c53c2c6b8c6" }, { "source_node_id": "sau:directorate-coordination", "target_node_id": "sau:third-level", "relationship": "coordinates described out-of-region referral route", "relationship_family": "governance", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:4f72f8c2649abdfaff5765d7" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:4f72f8c2649abdfaff5765d7" } ] }, "title": "Ehalati describes a referral route, not observed patient journeys", "statement": "The Ministry FAQ supports a formal multi-level and regional referral design. It does not establish how the route operates in practice.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Referral Program (Ehalati): FAQs, retrieved 2026.", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/structure/programs/referral/pages/faq.aspx", "locator": "FAQ section: What are the paths of referral?", "period": "Ministry FAQ retrieved 2026", "territory": "Ministry referral program within Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "referral_design", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "governance" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Referral Program (Ehalati): FAQs", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Referral Program (Ehalati): FAQs. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/structure/programs/referral/pages/faq.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/structure/programs/referral/pages/faq.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "What are the paths of referral?", "source_word_anchor": "from the first to the second level", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "1f9980f8993c91082856c59237dd4a32b041bef5cd2800cf024d7078e5181c47", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-ehalati-faq-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "1f9980f8993c91082856c59237dd4a32b041bef5cd2800cf024d7078e5181c47", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:c3da6392e3e1e65c46e56495" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:e5b84272d177a61deb10e353" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:9079df1c7a69a710c8148fe4", "display-claim:c1e7d45642f37d9ab0c180bf", "display-claim:ddae3383e5f00ffa04ed1c0e", "display-claim:3d0225f8a264a33abb76e723", "display-claim:3e61b4df79dc0c132d16cfcb", "display-claim:6a086bafd5110c9a65228766", "display-claim:84005cdc20175c53c2c6b8c6", "display-claim:4f72f8c2649abdfaff5765d7" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:9079df1c7a69a710c8148fe4", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:relationships-networks:public-private-boundary", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "target_view": "public-private", "target_slot": "public-private-and-purchasing-boundary", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "2018 delivery plan, current Ministry strategy page and 2024 systematic review", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-healthcare-transformation-strategy-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:phc-privatisation-systematic-review-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "formal": "The plan and strategy set out transformation and value-based-service intent.", "reported": "The review synthesizes privatization and primary-care evidence from 18 studies.", "boundary": "No cited source here supplies a current denominator-specific public-private ownership, delivery, expenditure, workforce or purchasing share." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_organizations": [ { "label": "Public, state-owned and private-sector providers", "ownership": "Transformation and privatization context", "scope": "No current comparable ownership or delivery share is supplied.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:eb8f4de18bcb34fc750aa708" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:54860093acb9c4fa77c8bb46", "display-source:SAU:f0bbef6864931ce77ebafd1b" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:fec401e3ba7bd45e9d3d0663", "display-source-version:5f66178353d2832c3ff01e29" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:eb8f4de18bcb34fc750aa708" } ] }, "title": "Public-private relationships remain denominator-bound", "statement": "Transformation and review materials provide policy and study context, not a current national public-private market or purchasing map.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, HSTP Delivery Plan, 2018; Healthcare Transformation Strategy, retrieved 2026; Albaher and Alqurashi, 2024.", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "locator": "HSTP Delivery Plan, Institutional transformation; strategy page; systematic review Abstract.", "period": "2018 plan, 2024 review and 2026 retrieved strategy page", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "ownership", "market_structure", "government_responsibilities", "decision_rights", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "governance", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan. 2018. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "pages": [ 48, 49 ], "sections": [ "Institutional transformation of healthcare facilities" ], "source_word_anchor": "separate the provision of health services from the Ministry", "source_word_count": 10 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4" }, { "title": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Healthcare Transformation Strategy. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "source_word_anchor": "roadmap towards providing value-based healthcare services", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "63cd1e5d1b18b0d5880684089d40633b570af2171c11c58d16437865550e9af4", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-healthcare-transformation-strategy-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:54860093acb9c4fa77c8bb46", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:fec401e3ba7bd45e9d3d0663" }, { "title": "Primary Healthcare Centre Improvement and Privatisation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: A Systematic Review", "citation": "Albaher Z, Alqurashi H. Primary Healthcare Centre Improvement and Privatisation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: A Systematic Review. Cureus. 2024;16(12):e76357. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Abstract", "source_word_anchor": "substantial gaps in critical domains", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "bee11643dc11f9f2db83c5f2c670400ac39de71c83e8d956632b625de05d0455", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:phc-privatisation-systematic-review-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:f0bbef6864931ce77ebafd1b", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:5f66178353d2832c3ff01e29" } ], "source_version": { "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:54860093acb9c4fa77c8bb46", "display-source:SAU:f0bbef6864931ce77ebafd1b" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:fec401e3ba7bd45e9d3d0663", "display-source-version:5f66178353d2832c3ff01e29" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:660a7ee277d1dde4e54c4e63", "display-claim:eb8f4de18bcb34fc750aa708" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:660a7ee277d1dde4e54c4e63", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:time-reform:formal-reform-and-observed-boundary", "country_id": "SAU", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "target_view": "reforms", "target_slot": "delivery-plan-holding-company-branches-and-care-paths", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "2018 delivery plan, 2024 Ministry announcement, 2023 annual-report material and 2019-2021 case study", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-branches-news-2024", "country-improvement-source:SAU:hstp-annual-report-2023", "country-improvement-source:SAU:ehalati-case-study-2022" ], "typed_fields": { "2018": "The HSTP Delivery Plan sets out a proposed institutional-transformation initiative and phases.", "2023": "The annual report records program-reported activity and indicators for 2023.", "2024": "The Ministry announcement reports branch transformation and a transition sequence involving clusters and the Health Holding Company.", "observed_context": "The e-referral study observes one bounded referral setting from 2019-2021.", "effect_boundary": "No displayed source causally links the reform objects to referral volumes, autonomy, patient choice, quality or national performance." }, "analytical_objects": { "reform_events": [ { "event_id": "sau:reform:2018-hstp-delivery-plan", "label": "Health Sector Transformation Program delivery plan publishes institutional-transformation proposal", "year": 2018, "status": "formal plan", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:1ac3f6d74905a527e1973cd8" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c", "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:1ac3f6d74905a527e1973cd8" }, { "event_id": "sau:reform:2023-hstp-report", "label": "Health Sector Transformation Program reports 2023 activity", "year": 2023, "status": "reported annual-program context", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:dde68cb9383db05f2b94a53c" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c", "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:dde68cb9383db05f2b94a53c" }, { "event_id": "sau:reform:2024-moh-branches", "label": "Ministry announces health-affairs directorate transformation into Ministry branches", "year": 2024, "status": "reported Ministry announcement", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:396736c6735cd18bdb309094" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c", "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:396736c6735cd18bdb309094" }, { "event_id": "sau:observation:2019-2021-ehalati-case", "label": "One e-referral case study observes referrals from nine PHC centres to one hospital", "year": 2021, "status": "observed local context, not reform evaluation", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:1ba2640b97949ad6526a077a" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c", "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:1ba2640b97949ad6526a077a" } ] }, "title": "Reform objects and local referral observation are not causal evidence", "statement": "The timeline distinguishes a formal plan, reported program and administrative milestones, and a separate local observed referral study. It does not claim these reforms caused national delivery changes.", "citation": "Ministry of Health, HSTP Delivery Plan, 2018; Ministry of Health news release, 2024; HSTP Annual Report 2023; Alabbasi et al., 2022.", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "locator": "HSTP Delivery Plan, Institutional transformation; Ministry news release, Page Content; HSTP Annual Report 2023, Foreword and Executive summary; Ehalati study, Methods and Results.", "period": "2018-2024 reform materials; local e-referral observations 2019-2021", "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, with a bounded e-referral study setting", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan. 2018. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "pages": [ 48, 49 ], "sections": [ "Institutional transformation of healthcare facilities" ], "source_word_anchor": "separate the provision of health services from the Ministry", "source_word_count": 10 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4" }, { "title": "Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA", "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA. 18 July 2024. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Page Content", "source_word_anchor": "separating organizational and supervisory roles", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "7647dee35a53afbff87c77ff4e0c578a2353897e2bec51f25e30e54361314472", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-branches-news-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4" }, { "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023", "citation": "Health Sector Transformation Program. Annual Report 2023. 2024. https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf", "url": "https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "pages": [ 5, 6 ], "sections": [ "Foreword", "Executive summary" ], "source_word_anchor": "annual report on the healthcare sector's achievements", "source_word_count": 7 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "5ed695f5db8a5f71c5d5280fa3919ab88f4ee9b4f10f50d1421f6ba65d4c57cc", "response_sha256": "5ed695f5db8a5f71c5d5280fa3919ab88f4ee9b4f10f50d1421f6ba65d4c57cc", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:hstp-annual-report-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c" }, { "title": "Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study", "citation": "Alabbasi KH, Kruger E, Tennant M. Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study. Clinics and Practice. 2022;12(3):364-377. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Materials and Methods; Results", "source_word_anchor": "52,143 referrals from the 9 designated PHC centres", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "97f53501b1878990383df69245e34247c61f0c2b0dd174889db8b20b3d8aa589", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:SAU:ehalati-case-study-2022", "display_source_id": "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" } ], "source_version": { "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:SAU:cc26c956f730e6132280c289", "display-source:SAU:0680ec168c606fb423e910a0", "display-source:SAU:d676ce59fbcea25d78ee5501", "display-source:SAU:0ec8ee4e6f3ecb21f1dc0665" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:2d93d15c814de9fb91c168b4", "display-source-version:9c8162380ad4295df84d30b4", "display-source-version:545456eb8d42b7e2cea4b43c", "display-source-version:6d12b1e20eb7513f2939eefb" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:58cdbcc7556a8f2e966d75a4", "display-claim:1ac3f6d74905a527e1973cd8", "display-claim:dde68cb9383db05f2b94a53c", "display-claim:396736c6735cd18bdb309094", "display-claim:1ba2640b97949ad6526a077a" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:58cdbcc7556a8f2e966d75a4", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" } ], "displayed_evidence": { "candidate_sources": [ { "candidate_source_id": "candidate-source:SAU:a6b5a13820cf9a2d5cc0", "evidence_layer": "candidate_corpus_page_locator", "evidence_layers": [ "candidate_corpus_page_locator" ], "source_layers": [ "candidate_corpus_page_locator" ], "source_type": "candidate corpus source", "display_eligible": true, "title": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments", "citation": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments. 2026. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf", "citation_string": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments. 2026. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf", "citation_status": "machine_formatted_from_title_year_url", "citation_provenance": "machine formatted from source title, publication year, and URL", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf", "publication_year": 2026, "source_families": [ "global_corpus" ], "channels": [ "corpus_excerpt_queue" ], "verification_source_layer": "grey_literature", "coverage_domains": [], "url_verification_status": null, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "dca67d8f25643c04c3f788ec2c6cec75a753ac3d6bfcc8bc898de6b5628e0940", "text_sha256": "7771f71099bba9bed20ada4090e5d5fd946eecc5de8765a6e8b88f8f9377f7af", "response_sha256": null, "page_count": null }, "locator": { "physical_pdf_page": 12, "source_word_anchor": "provision 1 Th e governance function of a country s LTC system" }, "display_status": "shown_in_full", "review_channel": "text_anchored_annotation", "verification_requirements": [] }, { "candidate_source_id": "candidate-source:SAU:18a54e9af124c350b0ec", "evidence_layer": "candidate_source_metadata", "evidence_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_type": "candidate source metadata", "display_eligible": true, "title": "Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "citation": "WHO Publications Bibliographic API. Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. WHO Publications Bibliographic API; 2024. https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf", "citation_string": "WHO Publications Bibliographic API. Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. WHO Publications Bibliographic API; 2024. https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf", "citation_status": "supplied", "citation_provenance": "source metadata", "url": "https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf", "publication_year": 2024, "source_families": [ "global_literature" ], "channels": [ "grey_library" ], "verification_source_layer": "grey_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "primary_care" ], "url_verification_status": null, "source_version": { "file_sha256": null, "text_sha256": null, "response_sha256": null, "page_count": null }, "locator": null, "display_status": "shown_in_full", "review_channel": "text_anchored_annotation", "verification_requirements": [] }, { "candidate_source_id": "candidate-source:SAU:000cdb7afc1412379ac0", "evidence_layer": "candidate_source_metadata", "evidence_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_type": "candidate source metadata", "display_eligible": true, "title": "How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia", "citation": "World Bank Documents and Reports. How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia. World Bank Documents and Reports; 2017. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf", "citation_string": "World Bank Documents and Reports. How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia. World Bank Documents and Reports; 2017. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf", "citation_status": "supplied", "citation_provenance": "source metadata", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf", "publication_year": 2017, "source_families": [ "global_literature" ], "channels": [ "grey_library" ], "verification_source_layer": "grey_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities" ], "url_verification_status": null, "source_version": { "file_sha256": null, "text_sha256": null, "response_sha256": null, "page_count": null }, "locator": null, "display_status": "shown_in_full", "review_channel": "text_anchored_annotation", "verification_requirements": [] } ], "candidate_facts": [], "exact_contexts": [] }, "evidence_scorecard": { "country_id": "SAU", "audit_passed": true, "preparation_stage": "direct_typed_mapping", "preparation_stage_label": "Explicit analytical mappings", "scores": { "analytical_mapping_groups": { "denominator": 5, "numerator": 5, "score": 100, "unit": "explicit analytical object groups" }, "controlled_domain_leads": { "denominator": 17, "numerator": 17, "score": 100, "unit": "controlled domains with displayed candidate leads" }, "material_locator_coverage": { "denominator": 42, "numerator": 36, "score": 86, "unit": "material records with an exact locator" }, "material_url_coverage": { "denominator": 42, "numerator": 42, "score": 100, "unit": "material records with at least one public URL" }, "material_version_coverage": { "denominator": 42, "numerator": 42, "score": 100, "unit": "material records with an immutable source version" }, "source_layer_presence": { "denominator": 3, "numerator": 3, "score": 100, "unit": "displayed candidate-source layers" } }, "represented_domain_ids": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "missing_domain_ids": [], "direct_typed_domain_ids": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "priority_actions": [ { "action_id": "annotate-country-synthesis", "detail": "All six preparation dimensions meet the target. Every source-linked finding and supporting material remains open for correction, qualification, and additional evidence through annotations.", "label": "Review and annotate the country synthesis" } ], "review_ready_material_ids": [ "material:f68a064817fc92aac30bb637", "material:edf7c70737d511fa4c0e592a", "material:e7c39b9bf69ec0ea770cf103", "material:d8d302730ae3314587f8dae7", "material:d6b05ae423bd39a8acafaa70" ], "full_scorecard_url": "https://wb-works.site/tools/health-organization/data/evidence-scorecards.json" }, "materials": [ { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Ministry corporatization and transformation-strategy descriptions", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:decision-autonomy:accountability-boundary", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-healthcare-transformation-strategy-2026" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "autonomy-and-accountability-boundary", "target_view": "autonomy", "typed_fields": { "accountability_boundary": "The displayed material does not specify a current enforceable accountability mechanism or provider autonomy by financial, workforce, procurement, operational and clinical domain.", "boundary": "Policy description is not evidence of actual autonomy or accountable-care results.", "formal": "The Ministry describes reduced centralized decision-making and a strategy toward value-based services." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Corporatization overview; Healthcare Transformation Strategy, retrieved 2026.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy page; Corporatization overview, Overview." }, "material_id": "material:ad622e3391ed226869395b1e", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Ministry pages retrieved 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd" }, "statement": "The sources state institutional aims but do not document current autonomy or accountability arrangements by decision domain.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Autonomy and accountability cannot be rated from the displayed sources", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Ministry Ehalati FAQ", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:relationships-networks:formal-ehalati-route", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-ehalati-faq-2026" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "formal-ehalati-level-and-regional-route", "target_view": "referrals", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "The design does not measure completed transitions, counter-referrals, bypassing or patient choice.", "formal_referral_design": "The FAQ describes first-to-second and second-to-third level referral routes, plus directorate-level coordination for referral outside a region." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Referral Program (Ehalati): FAQs, retrieved 2026.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "FAQ section: What are the paths of referral?" }, "material_id": "material:d3d9467d1437ac5ee8da8cef", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Ministry FAQ retrieved 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "1f9980f8993c91082856c59237dd4a32b041bef5cd2800cf024d7078e5181c47" }, "statement": "The Ministry FAQ supports a formal multi-level and regional referral design. It does not establish how the route operates in practice.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ministry referral program within Saudi Arabia", "title": "Ehalati describes a referral route, not observed patient journeys", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/structure/programs/referral/pages/faq.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "2011 peer-reviewed health-system overview", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:actors-functions:dated-system-review-context", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:health-system-overview-2011" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "dated-system-review-context", "target_view": "functions", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "It is not a current legal allocation of Ministry, cluster, insurer, regulator, or provider functions.", "reported": "The 2011 review synthesizes the health-system organization of its assessment period." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Almalki, FitzGerald and Clark. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. 2011;17(10):784-793.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "ownership" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Article title and review page; source dated 2011." }, "material_id": "material:c5959bf9e729d7dede76d05f", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2011 review", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "ddec30a0634f0981b104beb94ab31f59a34a4a2a8b4e1fc222e3c60feb1c5124" }, "statement": "The review is retained as dated organizational context and is not used to infer current roles.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Historical system review supplies dated context only", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-17/volume-17-issue-10/article-11.html" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Ministry corporatization overview and July 2024 Ministry announcement", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:actors-functions:formal-stewardship-and-clusters", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-branches-news-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "formal-stewardship-and-cluster-description", "target_view": "functions", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "Neither source supplies a complete current authority matrix or independently verifies operating practice.", "formal": "The Ministry describes organizing and supervising roles and describes Health Holding Company-supervised clusters as delivery arrangements.", "reported": "The July 2024 announcement reports regional directorates being transformed into Ministry branches." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities, retrieved 2026; Ministry of Health news release, 18 July 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Corporatization overview, Overview; 18 July 2024 news release, Page Content." }, "material_id": "material:c5b751be404d0250bdb00eef", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2024 announcement and 2026 retrieved Ministry description", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd" }, "statement": "Ministry sources describe a stewardship and delivery separation involving Ministry supervision and health clusters. This is formal or reported institutional material, not a complete current function map.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Ministry stewardship and cluster roles are described, not independently verified", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Retrospective e-referral case study", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:delivery-referrals:observed-ehalati-case", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:ehalati-case-study-2022" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "observed-nine-centre-ehalati-referrals", "target_view": "referrals", "typed_fields": { "observed": "The study records 52,143 sequential referrals from nine designated PHC centres to one receiving hospital between 2019 and 2021.", "scope_boundary": "The study's facilities, districts and time window cannot establish a national referral-completion, bypass or patient-choice rate." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Alabbasi, Kruger and Tennant. Clinics and Practice. 2022;12(3):364-377.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Materials and Methods; Results." }, "material_id": "material:210c5f8d0581cf1bcfe1eee0", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "1 January 2019 to 30 December 2021", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "97f53501b1878990383df69245e34247c61f0c2b0dd174889db8b20b3d8aa589" }, "statement": "A case study observed referrals from nine centres to one hospital during 2019-2021. It is empirical local evidence, not national referral performance.", "tags": [], "territory": "Nine designated PHC centres covering 34 districts and one receiving hospital, Saudi Arabia", "title": "Observed e-referrals are site- and time-bounded", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "2018 delivery plan, current Ministry strategy page and 2024 systematic review", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:relationships-networks:public-private-boundary", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-healthcare-transformation-strategy-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:phc-privatisation-systematic-review-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "public-private-and-purchasing-boundary", "target_view": "public-private", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "No cited source here supplies a current denominator-specific public-private ownership, delivery, expenditure, workforce or purchasing share.", "formal": "The plan and strategy set out transformation and value-based-service intent.", "reported": "The review synthesizes privatization and primary-care evidence from 18 studies." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, HSTP Delivery Plan, 2018; Healthcare Transformation Strategy, retrieved 2026; Albaher and Alqurashi, 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "ownership", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "HSTP Delivery Plan, Institutional transformation; strategy page; systematic review Abstract." }, "material_id": "material:64e1b8d8b3de48cb97aac424", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2018 plan, 2024 review and 2026 retrieved strategy page", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69" }, "statement": "Transformation and review materials provide policy and study context, not a current national public-private market or purchasing map.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Public-private relationships remain denominator-bound", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "2018 delivery plan, 2024 Ministry announcement, 2023 annual-report material and 2019-2021 case study", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:time-reform:formal-reform-and-observed-boundary", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-branches-news-2024", "country-improvement-source:SAU:hstp-annual-report-2023", "country-improvement-source:SAU:ehalati-case-study-2022" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "delivery-plan-holding-company-branches-and-care-paths", "target_view": "reforms", "typed_fields": { "2018": "The HSTP Delivery Plan sets out a proposed institutional-transformation initiative and phases.", "2023": "The annual report records program-reported activity and indicators for 2023.", "2024": "The Ministry announcement reports branch transformation and a transition sequence involving clusters and the Health Holding Company.", "effect_boundary": "No displayed source causally links the reform objects to referral volumes, autonomy, patient choice, quality or national performance.", "observed_context": "The e-referral study observes one bounded referral setting from 2019-2021." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, HSTP Delivery Plan, 2018; Ministry of Health news release, 2024; HSTP Annual Report 2023; Alabbasi et al., 2022.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "facility_data", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "HSTP Delivery Plan, Institutional transformation; Ministry news release, Page Content; HSTP Annual Report 2023, Foreword and Executive summary; Ehalati study, Methods and Results." }, "material_id": "material:35d2944ceb8d2f7968242d52", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2018-2024 reform materials; local e-referral observations 2019-2021", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69" }, "statement": "The timeline distinguishes a formal plan, reported program and administrative milestones, and a separate local observed referral study. It does not claim these reforms caused national delivery changes.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, with a bounded e-referral study setting", "title": "Reform objects and local referral observation are not causal evidence", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023", "url": "https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Ministry Modern Healthcare Model page and HSTP Annual Report 2023", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:delivery-referrals:reported-care-path-delivery", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-modern-healthcare-model-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:hstp-annual-report-2023" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "reported-2023-care-path-context", "target_view": "delivery", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "These sources do not provide a common national delivery denominator, completed pathway rate, or causal performance estimate.", "reported": "The Ministry reports 2023 cluster care-path implementation and the program reports 2023 activity and indicators." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Modern Healthcare Model, retrieved 2026; Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023, published 2024.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Modern Healthcare Model, Healthcare Pathways; HSTP Annual Report 2023, Foreword and Executive summary." }, "material_id": "material:c81f7a400bc6c7b8d3671e64", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Reported 2023 implementation and annual-report period", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "7a1867bbb9e2c768e6e3625d6476de791acf247d3ec29d6cf7608411d1b38888" }, "statement": "The sources describe care pathways and 2023 program activity, without validating current nationwide pathway use or completion.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Reported care-path activity is not a national patient-flow measure", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/about/pages/definition-modern-healthcare-model.aspx" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023", "url": "https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "2024 systematic review of 18 studies", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:delivery-referrals:reviewed-phc-boundary", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:phc-privatisation-systematic-review-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "reviewed-phc-improvement-and-privatisation-boundary", "target_view": "delivery", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "Heterogeneous study evidence does not yield a current national capacity, ownership, utilization or referral-performance estimate.", "reported": "The review reports cross-study primary-care evidence on infrastructure, workforce, policy and reform context." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Albaher and Alqurashi. Cureus. 2024;16(12):e76357.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Abstract and Methods." }, "material_id": "material:7c35a8a5e766df287410fdd1", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Review published 2024; included studies have individual dates", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "bee11643dc11f9f2db83c5f2c670400ac39de71c83e8d956632b625de05d0455" }, "statement": "The systematic review adds bounded primary-care context but no current national delivery or market-share value.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, included-study settings", "title": "Review evidence cannot become a current national delivery estimate", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Ministry corporatization overview and 2018 delivery plan", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:SAU:decision-autonomy:cluster-decision-description", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-corporatization-overview-2026", "country-improvement-source:SAU:moh-hstp-guide-2018" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "described-cluster-operational-decisions", "target_view": "decisions", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "No autonomy score is inferred.", "decision_boundary": "They do not establish which decisions are currently delegated, by cluster, for budgets, procurement, capital, service mix or clinical governance.", "formal": "The sources describe intended cluster-related decisions on employment, maintenance and transfers." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Corporatization overview, retrieved 2026; Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan, 2018.", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Corporatization overview, Overview; HSTP Delivery Plan, Institutional transformation of healthcare facilities." }, "material_id": "material:2dc90fbbb5df730d9bcd9039", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2018 plan and 2026 retrieved description", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd" }, "statement": "Ministry sources describe selected cluster operational decisions but do not support a current comprehensive decision-rights matrix.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Some cluster decisions are described; the wider authority matrix is unclassified", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments. 2026. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": "provision 1 Th e governance function of a country s LTC system", "institution": null, "locator": { "physical_pdf_page": 12, "source_word_anchor": "provision 1 Th e governance function of a country s LTC system", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:f01bf3cc6d186c1812d3e66f", "notes": [], "origin": "global-corpus-excerpt-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "corpus_page_anchor", "record_kind_label": "Corpus Page Anchor", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "dca67d8f25643c04c3f788ec2c6cec75a753ac3d6bfcc8bc898de6b5628e0940", "page_count": 61, "text_sha256": "7771f71099bba9bed20ada4090e5d5fd946eecc5de8765a6e8b88f8f9377f7af" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "language:en", "source:World Bank Documents and Reports", "source_layer:global_literature" ], "territory": null, "title": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments", "urls": [ { "kind": "stable_source_url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA. 18 July 2024. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "ownership", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "separating organizational and supervisory roles", "institution": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Page Content", "source_word_anchor": "separating organizational and supervisory roles", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:a9d8d696da79c967db4b7332", "notes": [ "Use this as a dated Ministry announcement, not a complete current organisation chart or an observed delivery-performance evaluation." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Ministry announcement dated 18 July 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "7647dee35a53afbff87c77ff4e0c578a2353897e2bec51f25e30e54361314472" }, "statement": "The Ministry reported that health-affairs directorates were being transformed into Ministry branches and described a reform sequence involving Health Holding Company establishment, health clusters and transition phases; the announcement does not verify every branch's subsequent operation.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, regional and provincial Ministry branches", "title": "Health Affairs Units Transformed into MoH Branches Across KSA", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/mediacenter/news/pages/news-2024-07-18-001.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Health Sector Transformation Program. Annual Report 2023. 2024. https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "annual report on the healthcare sector's achievements", "institution": "Health Sector Transformation Program, Saudi Vision 2030", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "source_word_anchor": "annual report on the healthcare sector's achievements", "source_word_count": 7 }, "material_id": "material:edf7c70737d511fa4c0e592a", "notes": [ "Keep reported programme indicators in their 2023 denominators and avoid treating them as proof of current national performance or causal reform effects." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Annual report for calendar year 2023, published 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "5ed695f5db8a5f71c5d5280fa3919ab88f4ee9b4f10f50d1421f6ba65d4c57cc", "response_sha256": "5ed695f5db8a5f71c5d5280fa3919ab88f4ee9b4f10f50d1421f6ba65d4c57cc" }, "statement": "The program's 2023 annual report presents its own reported transformation activity and indicators for that year; it cannot establish current national practice, causal effects, or a complete patient-flow measure.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Annual Report 2023", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.vision2030.gov.sa/media/xznnx3vz/hstp-annual-report-2023-en.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan. 2018. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "separate the provision of health services from the Ministry", "institution": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_section", "source_word_anchor": "separate the provision of health services from the Ministry", "source_word_count": 10 }, "material_id": "material:e7c39b9bf69ec0ea770cf103", "notes": [ "Keep proposed phases and targets separate from verified implementation, provider decision rights, and patient outcomes." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Delivery plan published 2018; its initiatives and milestones are period-specific", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2018, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69", "response_sha256": "0dd8e5a6812225cc5f3c8617ea904b0148ebb15de471126b8ea5d6d5482b8d69" }, "statement": "The 2018 delivery plan sets out a proposed institutional-transformation initiative, including separation of Ministry provision from regulation and supervision and a phased cluster model; it is a plan, not proof that each stated arrangement occurred or persists.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Health Sector Transformation Program Delivery Plan", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Documents/HSTP-Guide-EN.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Almalki M, FitzGerald G, Clark M. Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. 2011;17(10):784-793. https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-17/volume-17-issue-10/article-11.html", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "facility_data", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "ownership", "primary_care", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview", "institution": "Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal (peer-reviewed journal)", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading", "section": "Article title and review", "source_word_anchor": "Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:d6b05ae423bd39a8acafaa70", "notes": [ "Maintain the 2011 review's date; do not use it to state current practice, current national performance, or a complete current decision-rights matrix." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Health-system overview published 2011 using its cited historical data", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2011, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "ddec30a0634f0981b104beb94ab31f59a34a4a2a8b4e1fc222e3c60feb1c5124" }, "statement": "The 2011 review offers a dated synthesis of Saudi health-system organization, financing, provision and workforce context; it cannot establish current authority allocations, ownership proportions, or present delivery performance.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Health care system in Saudi Arabia: an overview", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-17/volume-17-issue-10/article-11.html" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Healthcare Transformation Strategy. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "market_structure", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "roadmap towards providing value-based healthcare services", "institution": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "source_word_anchor": "roadmap towards providing value-based healthcare services", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:3af397824d757221fa394ad4", "notes": [ "Represent this as strategic intent and methodology, not measured value-based purchasing or achieved service effects." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Ministry strategy page retrieved 22 August 2026; page states last update 14 June 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "63cd1e5d1b18b0d5880684089d40633b570af2171c11c58d16437865550e9af4" }, "statement": "The Ministry describes the Healthcare Transformation Strategy as a Vision Realization Office methodology and roadmap toward value-based services and expenditure control; the page does not demonstrate implementation, provider autonomy, or effects.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Healthcare Transformation Strategy", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/vro/pages/health-transformation-strategy.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Modern Healthcare Model. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/about/pages/definition-modern-healthcare-model.aspx", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "health clusters implemented medical care paths", "institution": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Healthcare Pathways", "source_word_anchor": "health clusters implemented medical care paths", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:d8d302730ae3314587f8dae7", "notes": [ "The Ministry's reported care paths do not evidence universal access, actual transfer completion, or comparative quality across clusters." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Ministry page retrieved 22 August 2026; it describes 2023 care-path implementation", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "7a1867bbb9e2c768e6e3625d6476de791acf247d3ec29d6cf7608411d1b38888" }, "statement": "The Ministry reports that health clusters implemented specified care paths during 2023 and describes paths across primary care, hospitals and medical cities; this is reported program context, not a national measure of pathway completion.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Modern Healthcare Model", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/about/pages/definition-modern-healthcare-model.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "free the health clusters from centralized decision-making", "institution": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Overview", "source_word_anchor": "free the health clusters from centralized decision-making", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:1366ea1229456bca06e1b44a", "notes": [ "Treat the page as the Ministry's institutional description; do not infer completed separation, actual cluster discretion, or national performance." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Ministry web description retrieved 22 August 2026; page states last update 6 May 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "22edb0f11268d005612ac7e185126365198790f12606dc05a4374889137ea5dd" }, "statement": "The Ministry describes a corporatization model in which it is to organize and supervise the sector, while state-owned Health Holding Company-supervised regional business units and health clusters are described as delivery arrangements; this is an institutional description, not evidence of national implementation or performance.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Overview of Corporatization of Healthcare Facilities", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/Ministry/vro/Corporatization/Pages/default.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Albaher Z, Alqurashi H. Primary Healthcare Centre Improvement and Privatisation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: A Systematic Review. Cureus. 2024;16(12):e76357. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "reform_history", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "substantial gaps in critical domains", "institution": "Cureus (peer-reviewed journal)", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Abstract", "source_word_anchor": "substantial gaps in critical domains", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:5c4dd029a1123a3a6a059d93", "notes": [ "Do not turn this multi-study synthesis into a current national market-share, autonomy, or patient-flow claim." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Systematic review published 2024; 18 included studies with study-specific dates and settings", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "bee11643dc11f9f2db83c5f2c670400ac39de71c83e8d956632b625de05d0455" }, "statement": "The systematic review synthesizes 18 studies on Saudi primary-care improvement and privatization, reporting context-specific gaps in care coordination and access; it does not supply a current national ownership share, referral rate, or reform-effect estimate.", "tags": [], "territory": "Kingdom of Saudi Arabia; evidence drawn from the review's included studies", "title": "Primary Healthcare Centre Improvement and Privatisation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: A Systematic Review", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11758590/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Referral Program (Ehalati): FAQs. Retrieved 22 August 2026. https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/structure/programs/referral/pages/faq.aspx", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "from the first to the second level", "institution": "Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "What are the paths of referral?", "source_word_anchor": "from the first to the second level", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:f68a064817fc92aac30bb637", "notes": [ "Do not treat a stated route as evidence of gatekeeping, completed counter-referral, patient choice, or national pathway performance." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Ministry FAQ page retrieved 22 August 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "1f9980f8993c91082856c59237dd4a32b041bef5cd2800cf024d7078e5181c47" }, "statement": "The FAQ describes a referral design from first to second level and from second to third level, with specified regional and directorate coordination routes; it does not quantify completed referrals, bypassing, or current use.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ministry referral program within the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia", "title": "Referral Program (Ehalati): FAQs", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.moh.gov.sa/en/ministry/structure/programs/referral/pages/faq.aspx" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Alabbasi KH, Kruger E, Tennant M. Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study. Clinics and Practice. 2022;12(3):364-377. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "networks", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": "52,143 referrals from the 9 designated PHC centres", "institution": "Healthcare (peer-reviewed journal)", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_section", "section": "Materials and Methods; Results", "source_word_anchor": "52,143 referrals from the 9 designated PHC centres", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:19b3c2bc0cfab35c16ba1e83", "notes": [ "Preserve the nine-centre, one-receiving-hospital and 2019-2021 boundaries; do not generalize observed referrals to national routine performance." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Sequential referrals from 1 January 2019 to 30 December 2021; article published 2022", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2022, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "97f53501b1878990383df69245e34247c61f0c2b0dd174889db8b20b3d8aa589" }, "statement": "This retrospective case study observed 52,143 referrals from nine designated primary-health-care centres to one receiving hospital during 2019-2021; it is not a national referral-completion, bypass, or patient-choice estimate.", "tags": [], "territory": "Nine designated primary-health-care centres covering 34 districts and their receiving hospital; Saudi Arabia", "title": "Strengthening Saudi Arabia's Primary Health Care through an e-Referral System: A Case Study", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9222003/" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments. 2026. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "candidate corpus source", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "physical_pdf_page": 12, "source_word_anchor": "provision 1 Th e governance function of a country s LTC system" }, "material_id": "candidate-source:SAU:a6b5a13820cf9a2d5cc0", "notes": [ "Public source projection retained as a distinct stage record." ], "origin": "current-public-source-projection", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "displayed_source_projection", "record_kind_label": "Displayed source projection", "screening": { "previous_visibility": "previously_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "candidate_corpus_page_locator", "grey_literature" ], "source_system": "global_corpus", "source_version": { "file_sha256": "dca67d8f25643c04c3f788ec2c6cec75a753ac3d6bfcc8bc898de6b5628e0940", "text_sha256": "7771f71099bba9bed20ada4090e5d5fd946eecc5de8765a6e8b88f8f9377f7af" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "corpus_excerpt_queue" ], "territory": null, "title": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "World Bank Documents and Reports. How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia. World Bank Documents and Reports; 2017. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "candidate source metadata", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 2, "physical_pdf_page": 7, "source_word_anchor": "licensing directorate at the Ministry of Health focusing specifically on licensing for", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "candidate-source:SAU:000cdb7afc1412379ac0", "notes": [ "Public source projection retained as a distinct stage record.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "current-public-source-projection", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2017, "record_kind": "displayed_source_projection", "record_kind_label": "Displayed source projection", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_projected", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata", "grey_literature" ], "source_system": "global_literature", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 22, "response_sha256": "5fc6ab6b4d3831e14ed115e4b940bdfce6763837e0f46829905c6131edf92b15" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "grey_library" ], "territory": null, "title": "How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO Publications Bibliographic API. Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. WHO Publications Bibliographic API; 2024. https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "candidate source metadata", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": null, "material_id": "candidate-source:SAU:18a54e9af124c350b0ec", "notes": [ "Public source projection retained as a distinct stage record.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "current-public-source-projection", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "displayed_source_projection", "record_kind_label": "Displayed source projection", "screening": { "previous_visibility": "previously_projected", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata", "grey_literature" ], "source_system": "global_literature", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "a859cc83d11508435744f1ce4fb6f39396083c22e60bea3f872887eb2dd1863f" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "grey_library" ], "territory": null, "title": "Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "url_status": "available" }, "citation": "World Bank Documents and Reports. How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia. World Bank Documents and Reports; 2017. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "unknown", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 2, "physical_pdf_page": 7, "source_word_anchor": "licensing directorate at the Ministry of Health focusing specifically on licensing for", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:5580db7f748e49436c8ac73e", "notes": [ "Catalogue lead displayed in full for source and claim annotation.", "Catalogue geography, title matching, and taxonomy tags require human confirmation.", "No source bytes, exact locator, or atomic claim has been reviewed by the Health Organization registry.", "Grey literature does not by itself establish current formal authority.", "Catalogue ISO3 jurisdiction and an explicit metadata country alias in the title both matched.", "Catalogue marks source bytes as downloaded.", "Catalogue marks text as extracted.", "Catalogue has organization-relevant topic tags: health_workforce.", "Source family: global_literature.", "Title signal: health_system.", "Published in 2010 or later.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-grey-source-leads", "period": null, "publication_date": "2017-01-31", "publication_year": 2017, "record_kind": "grey_literature_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Grey Literature Source Lead", "screening": { "candidate_status": "candidate", "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "unreviewed", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "status": "candidate", "triage_status": "new" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "global_literature", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 22, "response_sha256": "5fc6ab6b4d3831e14ed115e4b940bdfce6763837e0f46829905c6131edf92b15" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "Catalogue ISO3 jurisdiction and an explicit metadata country alias in the title both matched.", "Catalogue has organization-relevant topic tags: health_workforce.", "Catalogue marks source bytes as downloaded.", "Catalogue marks text as extracted.", "Published in 2010 or later.", "Source family: global_literature.", "Title signal: health_system.", "catalogue_downloaded", "catalogue_extracted", "catalogue_iso3_match", "catalogue_topic:health_workforce", "catalogue_topic:pooling_insurance", "explicit_country_alias", "grey_literature", "health_system_organization", "title:health_system", "title_country_alias_match" ], "territory": null, "title": "How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia", "urls": [ { "kind": "stable_url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf" }, { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/text/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.txt" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "url_status": "available" }, "citation": "WHO Publications Bibliographic API. Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. WHO Publications Bibliographic API; 2024. https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "unknown", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "WHO Publications Bibliographic API", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:94024ffed7565525caffbd29", "notes": [ "Catalogue lead displayed in full for source and claim annotation.", "Catalogue geography, title matching, and taxonomy tags require human confirmation.", "No source bytes, exact locator, or atomic claim has been reviewed by the Health Organization registry.", "Grey literature does not by itself establish current formal authority.", "Catalogue ISO3 jurisdiction and an explicit metadata country alias in the title both matched.", "Catalogue has organization-relevant topic tags: primary_care.", "Source family: global_literature.", "Title signal: health_care.", "Title signal: primary_care.", "Published in 2020 or later.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-grey-source-leads", "period": null, "publication_date": "2024-02-29", "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "grey_literature_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Grey Literature Source Lead", "screening": { "candidate_status": "candidate", "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "unreviewed", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "status": "candidate", "triage_status": "new" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "global_literature", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "a859cc83d11508435744f1ce4fb6f39396083c22e60bea3f872887eb2dd1863f" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "Catalogue ISO3 jurisdiction and an explicit metadata country alias in the title both matched.", "Catalogue has organization-relevant topic tags: primary_care.", "Published in 2020 or later.", "Source family: global_literature.", "Title signal: health_care.", "Title signal: primary_care.", "catalogue_iso3_match", "catalogue_topic:primary_care", "explicit_country_alias", "grey_literature", "health_system_organization", "title:health_care", "title:primary_care", "title_country_alias_match" ], "territory": null, "title": "Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "stable_url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf" }, { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/api/news/bibliopublications" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/handle/10665/376145" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 191, "text_words": 78832 }, "citation": "A Labor Market Assessment of Nurses and Physicians in Saudi Arabia : Addressing Future Imbalances between Need, Supply, and Demand. 2021. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "accreditation_quality", "financial_protection", "health_financing", "health_information_systems", "health_workforce", "leadership_governance", "pooling_insurance", "primary_care", "public_private_mix", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "unknown", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 8, "source_word_anchor": "and physicians practicing in primary care f acilities and hospitals 20 1", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:d3d9cb5c371ade4ecfc609e7", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2021-01-01", "publication_year": 2021, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.7, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "be15d5a9dd9bbd1bb260dbc15886cdf6cc3911cb837cc5629d8726b1c9705d39", "page_count": 191, "text_sha256": "500e76cae16ae283000957778add3217aafe5f078430326ad126c8bc5f07e198" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "control_knob:persuasion_behaviour", "control_knob:regulation", "health_system_topic:accreditation_quality", "health_system_topic:financial_protection", "health_system_topic:health_workforce", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "health_system_topic:public_private_mix", "health_system_topic:service_delivery", "population_group:older_people", "sdg:3.8.2", "sdg:3.c.1", "service_area:cross_cutting", "service_area:hospital_care", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:health_information_systems", "who_building_block:health_workforce", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "A Labor Market Assessment of Nurses and Physicians in Saudi Arabia : Addressing Future Imbalances between Need, Supply, and Demand", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/830511632373746956/text/A-Labor-Market-Assessment-of-Nurses-and-Physicians-in-Saudi-Arabia-Addressing-Future-Imbalances-between-Need-Supply-and-Demand.txt" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/830511632373746956/pdf/A-Labor-Market-Assessment-of-Nurses-and-Physicians-in-Saudi-Arabia-Addressing-Future-Imbalances-between-Need-Supply-and-Demand.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/830511632373746956" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/830511632373746956/pdf/A-Labor-Market-Assessment-of-Nurses-and-Physicians-in-Saudi-Arabia-Addressing-Future-Imbalances-between-Need-Supply-and-Demand.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 61, "text_words": 20403 }, "citation": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments. 2026. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "emergency_preparedness", "health_financing", "leadership_governance", "pooling_insurance", "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "technical report", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 5, "source_word_anchor": "is collaboration of the Health Nutrition and Population and Social Protection and", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:1016e82e7b575a1a30f2ee11", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2026-03-07", "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "dca67d8f25643c04c3f788ec2c6cec75a753ac3d6bfcc8bc898de6b5628e0940", "page_count": 61, "text_sha256": "7771f71099bba9bed20ada4090e5d5fd946eecc5de8765a6e8b88f8f9377f7af" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "control_knob:regulation", "health_system_topic:emergency_preparedness", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "health_system_topic:service_delivery", "population_group:children", "population_group:older_people", "population_group:persons_with_disabilities", "service_area:cross_cutting", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Assessing Needs, Enabling Care : A Comparative Framework for Long-Term Care Needs Assessments", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/text/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.txt" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099030626135017117/pdf/P180684-1556c0cd-e1d6-4972-9d30-a4e9b118640f.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 54, "text_words": 20043 }, "citation": "Enhancing the effectiveness of external support in building tax capacity in developing countries : prepared for submission to G20 finance ministers. 2016. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "leadership_governance" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 3, "physical_pdf_page": 11, "source_word_anchor": "and improvements in public health services Ali Fjeldstad and Sjursen 2014 establish", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:fcdb5c5d012187904d4e148f", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2016-07-01", "publication_year": 2016, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "fd661f3efe89308e57720f6e6f3f9b2ea76421c7883dad3ef7021ba109a0a124", "page_count": 54, "text_sha256": "f7ec4a065ede4a1b49a06b7eb4b23ebd2d0d1be3c4132e699dd972363a79cd55" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "who_building_block:leadership_governance" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Enhancing the effectiveness of external support in building tax capacity in developing countries : prepared for submission to G20 finance ministers", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/337691503666961906/text/119100-WP-PUBLIC-World-Bank-Document.txt" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/337691503666961906/pdf/119100-WP-PUBLIC-World-Bank-Document.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/337691503666961906" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/337691503666961906/pdf/119100-WP-PUBLIC-World-Bank-Document.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 94, "text_words": 38290 }, "citation": "Health Policy Evaluation Guideline. 2025. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "accreditation_quality", "equity_inequality", "health_financing", "health_information", "leadership_governance", "pooling_insurance", "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "technical report", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 12, "source_word_anchor": "commitment to transparent evidence-informed governance the guideline is designed to support policy", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:1ff1ea73be3985306a1cfe02", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2025-11-21", "publication_year": 2025, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "58691db2a2673690eeece5e600c5746c150076e2e1336aa792327ad09ed5731b", "page_count": 94, "text_sha256": "26374e68739525ca03b8be90e3f66390377d522737e689d2048c76ce8dd4522f" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "health_system_topic:accreditation_quality", "health_system_topic:equity_inequality", "health_system_topic:health_information", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "health_system_topic:service_delivery", "service_area:cross_cutting", "service_area:immunization", "service_area:infectious_disease", "service_area:mental_health", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Health Policy Evaluation Guideline", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099103025105514748/text/P179873-6a26e11a-7b3a-4ea8-9f44-c8e9623db429.txt" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099103025105514748/pdf/P179873-6a26e11a-7b3a-4ea8-9f44-c8e9623db429.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099103025105514748" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099103025105514748/pdf/P179873-6a26e11a-7b3a-4ea8-9f44-c8e9623db429.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 114, "text_words": 30428 }, "citation": "Natural disasters in the Middle East and North Africa : a regional overview. 2014. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:3d757e1b910e2349728ec9e1", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2014-01-01", "publication_year": 2014, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "e6ec9a42c12eac11d8e45d44bc099fce507eb75cc3351df58a54620256882724", "page_count": 114, "text_sha256": "15ccb40a3869b10bfca45243539d768df57a2970659741959b893f51fea78aec" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Natural disasters in the Middle East and North Africa : a regional overview", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/211811468106752534/pdf/816580WP0REPLA0140same0box00PUBLIC0.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/211811468106752534/text/816580WP0REPLA0140same0box00PUBLIC0.txt" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/211811468106752534/pdf/816580WP0REPLA0140same0box00PUBLIC0.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/211811468106752534" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 116, "text_words": 35125 }, "citation": "Natural disasters in the Middle East and North Africa : a regional overview. 2014. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:f2505c6216838a8edfa33e30", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2014-01-01", "publication_year": 2014, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "0cac43751851cf77914dc98b0ccb4e88a99c4a865cd4e933325b94124f7bf678", "page_count": 116, "text_sha256": "6f3cfcc1ea9d660b99c2662b5ba4a35cee76a5a4663e842c6e1cc3f09eee68b8" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "population_group:rural_remote" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Natural disasters in the Middle East and North Africa : a regional overview", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/315791468108273774/pdf/816580FRENCH0N00Box385309B00PUBLIC0.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/315791468108273774/text/816580FRENCH0N00Box385309B00PUBLIC0.txt" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/315791468108273774" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/315791468108273774/pdf/816580FRENCH0N00Box385309B00PUBLIC0.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 41, "text_words": 19899 }, "citation": "Revenue sharing of natural resources in Africa : reflections from a review of international practices. 2014. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/890931468209041225", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "leadership_governance", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "heading": "1 THE ALLOCATION OF NRR AMONG LEVELS OF GOVERNMENTS", "paragraph_index_on_page": 4, "physical_pdf_page": 4, "source_word_anchor": "such as education and health During upturns in prices subnational jurisdictions would", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:1e908d675caffde7f7c5b9fc", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2014-04-01", "publication_year": 2014, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.7, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "311c2828337426857a4f49126f716e069cdb2880c274ff47c0199d889c623cb4", "page_count": 41, "text_sha256": "31dc4e0adf92f03e422c5f71a94281bb28c81e3d54f7dc5c25e8d7867ab65b70" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Revenue sharing of natural resources in Africa : reflections from a review of international practices", "urls": [ { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/890931468209041225" }, { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/890931468209041225/pdf/902520WP0P1437000Final00April020140.pdf" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/890931468209041225/pdf/902520WP0P1437000Final00April020140.pdf" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/890931468209041225/text/902520WP0P1437000Final00April020140.txt" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 21, "text_words": 522 }, "citation": "Shaping healthier societies and building higher performing health systems in the GCC countries (Vol. 1 of 2) : Main report. 2015. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/642021467998797645", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "accreditation_quality", "financial_protection", "health_financing", "leadership_governance", "medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "pooling_insurance", "primary_care", "provider_payment", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:42af9ef153a3e1dea5f4e940", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2015-04-01", "publication_year": 2015, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "ae97d5ad0fb09015f76bdc2778ed78ee87fce7c63c306dc094ed6511d1873e44", "page_count": 21, "text_sha256": "3271fa752b452f66d205bb2efaafd7595c09b43095eff6196cea65c5b0970f84" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "control_knob:payment", "control_knob:persuasion_behaviour", "control_knob:regulation", "health_system_topic:accreditation_quality", "health_system_topic:financial_protection", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "health_system_topic:provider_payment", "health_system_topic:service_delivery", "population_group:maternal", "sdg:3.8.2", "service_area:cross_cutting", "service_area:immunization", "service_area:infectious_disease", "service_area:maternal_reproductive", "service_area:ncd", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Shaping healthier societies and building higher performing health systems in the GCC countries (Vol. 1 of 2) : Main report", "urls": [ { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/642021467998797645" }, { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/642021467998797645/text/96393-v1-ARABIC-WP-PUBLIC-Box393185B.txt" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/642021467998797645/pdf/96393-v1-ARABIC-WP-PUBLIC-Box393185B.pdf" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/642021467998797645/pdf/96393-v1-ARABIC-WP-PUBLIC-Box393185B.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 17, "text_words": 5710 }, "citation": "Shaping healthier societies and building higher performing health systems in the GCC countries (Vol. 1 of 2) : Main report. 2015. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "accreditation_quality", "financial_protection", "health_financing", "leadership_governance", "medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "pooling_insurance", "primary_care", "provider_payment", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 1, "source_word_anchor": "performance financing populations insurance Ministry primary country also including level development particularly", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:a61a596ef89e18b73897fe31", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2015-04-01", "publication_year": 2015, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "af1062e38db68ec44b0ea4dfa112eeed4c269af3fc00e135072cfbfad6a92360", "page_count": 17, "text_sha256": "84f975c75bdf9c9538e22a105976941a5d01582ad5870b681e4a04fa172aa76b" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "control_knob:payment", "control_knob:persuasion_behaviour", "control_knob:regulation", "health_system_topic:accreditation_quality", "health_system_topic:financial_protection", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "health_system_topic:provider_payment", "health_system_topic:service_delivery", "population_group:maternal", "sdg:3.8.2", "service_area:cross_cutting", "service_area:immunization", "service_area:infectious_disease", "service_area:maternal_reproductive", "service_area:ncd", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Shaping healthier societies and building higher performing health systems in the GCC countries (Vol. 1 of 2) : Main report", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/907131468182345587/pdf/96393-WP-Health-Sector-Engagement-Note-Box391433B-PUBLIC.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/907131468182345587/text/96393-WP-Health-Sector-Engagement-Note-Box391433B-PUBLIC.txt" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/907131468182345587" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/907131468182345587/pdf/96393-WP-Health-Sector-Engagement-Note-Box391433B-PUBLIC.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 64, "text_words": 29661 }, "citation": "Somalia Economic Update : Impact of COVID-19 - Policies to Manage the Crisis and Strengthen Economic Recovery. 2020. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "leadership_governance", "medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "medicines_vaccines_devices" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 9, "source_word_anchor": "Direct Investment FGC Financial Governance Committee FGS Federal Government of Somalia FMIS", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:6170053d2a83d2757f8826a9", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2020-06-01", "publication_year": 2020, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "38220c19a52192c9347e399ff79d9cbfee24991a9e75468f6b50de290a0d0ede", "page_count": 64, "text_sha256": "a4ff88242fe972f6a6957af8a075ebbb991819a9cf30b6a578bbff190815b2df" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "health_system_topic:medicines_vaccines_devices", "service_area:cross_cutting", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:medical_products_vaccines_technologies" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Somalia Economic Update : Impact of COVID-19 - Policies to Manage the Crisis and Strengthen Economic Recovery", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/252881595627954924/pdf/Somalia-Economic-Update-Impact-of-COVID-19-Policies-to-Manage-the-Crisis-and-Strengthen-Economic-Recovery.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/252881595627954924/pdf/Somalia-Economic-Update-Impact-of-COVID-19-Policies-to-Manage-the-Crisis-and-Strengthen-Economic-Recovery.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/252881595627954924" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/252881595627954924/text/Somalia-Economic-Update-Impact-of-COVID-19-Policies-to-Manage-the-Crisis-and-Strengthen-Economic-Recovery.txt" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 3, "text_words": 1221 }, "citation": "Statement by Mohammed A. Al-Jadaan at the 101st meeting of the Development Committee held on April 17, 2020. 2020. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "technical report", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 3, "source_word_anchor": "address weak and overwhelmed health systems and mitigate the risk of social", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:389d52bdda4c8f460caae777", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2020-04-17", "publication_year": 2020, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "679a4619133e8e4eff90317f07ab9894d504d76de966fec9b8340ca1c1746ac8", "page_count": 3, "text_sha256": "498cde6e1ab4e54381b56dcc0e895a83ecba250c330619a9066ee915df88df91" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Statement by Mohammed A. Al-Jadaan at the 101st meeting of the Development Committee held on April 17, 2020", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/263661587606724446/pdf/Statement-by-Mohammed-A-Al-Jadaan-at-the-101st-meeting-of-the-Development-Committee-held-on-April-17-2020.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/263661587606724446/text/Statement-by-Mohammed-A-Al-Jadaan-at-the-101st-meeting-of-the-Development-Committee-held-on-April-17-2020.txt" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/263661587606724446/pdf/Statement-by-Mohammed-A-Al-Jadaan-at-the-101st-meeting-of-the-Development-Committee-held-on-April-17-2020.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/263661587606724446" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 84, "text_words": 30591 }, "citation": "Strengthening the Pharmaceutical System in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia : Towards a Medicine Policy to Support Vision 2030. 2021. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "accreditation_quality", "fiscal_space_budget", "health_financing", "leadership_governance", "medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "medicines_vaccines_devices", "pooling_insurance", "primary_care", "procurement_supply_chain", "provider_payment", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 2, "physical_pdf_page": 6, "source_word_anchor": "Government Procurement Authority MOH Ministry of Health NIDLP National Industrial Development and", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:e3c801e45ecf56fbf6792d1d", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2021-01-01", "publication_year": 2021, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.7, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "e3a9e366aad3b82cd10b46d06fc09c686d2f45da791cefaf291e2074f1c001a5", "page_count": 84, "text_sha256": "cad87fbe9176e67dc6837e37c4fdd31409079f48dfaa13152ad16a4c1fd698f6" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:financing", "control_knob:organization", "control_knob:payment", "control_knob:persuasion_behaviour", "control_knob:regulation", "health_system_topic:accreditation_quality", "health_system_topic:fiscal_space_budget", "health_system_topic:medicines_vaccines_devices", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "health_system_topic:procurement_supply_chain", "health_system_topic:provider_payment", "health_system_topic:service_delivery", "service_area:cross_cutting", "service_area:infectious_disease", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:medical_products_vaccines_technologies", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "Strengthening the Pharmaceutical System in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia : Towards a Medicine Policy to Support Vision 2030", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/305991624017831749/pdf/Strengthening-the-Pharmaceutical-System-in-the-Kingdom-of-Saudi-Arabia-Towards-a-Medicine-Policy-to-Support-Vision-2030.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/305991624017831749/pdf/Strengthening-the-Pharmaceutical-System-in-the-Kingdom-of-Saudi-Arabia-Towards-a-Medicine-Policy-to-Support-Vision-2030.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/305991624017831749" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/305991624017831749/text/Strengthening-the-Pharmaceutical-System-in-the-Kingdom-of-Saudi-Arabia-Towards-a-Medicine-Policy-to-Support-Vision-2030.txt" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 25, "text_words": 12162 }, "citation": "The Yemen social fund for development. 2004. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 12, "source_word_anchor": "as literacy activities the Ministry of Health through supporting the training of", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:7bb8392e188256226a1012bf", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2004-05-01", "publication_year": 2004, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "ab340a7cf18e08091b1cccb356c9699271a97afe9acfa7c11f868cbc2d61cd69", "page_count": 25, "text_sha256": "4afb0966e6215daf2d8efa4a6959b1a6f8fb6b7c7bcb6c310e01750ee6f3c76a" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "health_system_topic:primary_care", "population_group:children", "service_area:primary_care", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "The Yemen social fund for development", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/223261468763486232/pdf/308190YR0Social0Fund01see0also0307591.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/223261468763486232/text/308190YR0Social0Fund01see0also0307591.txt" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/223261468763486232" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/223261468763486232/pdf/308190YR0Social0Fund01see0also0307591.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 251, "text_words": 93247 }, "citation": "The way forward for social safety nets in the Middle East and North Africa. 2012. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "health_financing", "leadership_governance", "pooling_insurance", "service_delivery" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 5, "physical_pdf_page": 4, "source_word_anchor": "investments in education and health among the poor protect adults and children", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:2dc3245976b5f2f46f849a9e", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "2012-11-01", "publication_year": 2012, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.7, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "f10774241f41b3f054c82b9ebfaa0deaffe3121c741457535ea177be0f45eccc", "page_count": 251, "text_sha256": "29053586b5586307fa197918398c5e6e8289bda468909804434da0442a59dd5d" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "health_system_topic:pooling_insurance", "population_group:children", "population_group:maternal", "population_group:persons_with_disabilities", "population_group:rural_remote", "who_building_block:health_financing", "who_building_block:leadership_governance", "who_building_block:service_delivery" ], "territory": "national", "title": "The way forward for social safety nets in the Middle East and North Africa", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/462881468052823731/text/NonAsciiFileName0.txt" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/462881468052823731/pdf/NonAsciiFileName0.pdf" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/462881468052823731" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/462881468052823731/pdf/NonAsciiFileName0.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "World Bank Documents and Reports. How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia. World Bank Documents and Reports; 2017. https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 2, "physical_pdf_page": 7, "source_word_anchor": "licensing directorate at the Ministry of Health focusing specifically on licensing for", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:6c31982113d9f21586622244", "notes": [ "Verify the exact bibliographic citation against the original source.", "Confirm that the document applies to the named country and intended territorial scope.", "Confirm document type, issuing institution, authority, and claim-specific suitability.", "Retrieve and hash the exact source version when it is not already verified.", "Check publication date, effective period, currency, and supersession risk.", "Confirm only domains directly supported by the reviewed source.", "Add substantive feedback directly through the text-anchored annotation layer.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-source-triage-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2017, "record_kind": "source_triage_record", "record_kind_label": "Source Triage Record", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "global_literature", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 22, "response_sha256": "5fc6ab6b4d3831e14ed115e4b940bdfce6763837e0f46829905c6131edf92b15" }, "statement": null, "tags": [], "territory": null, "title": "How labor laws can transform health systems the case of Saudi Arabia", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/131041488191112659/pdf/113002-JRN-PUBLIC-How-Labor-Laws-Can-Transform-Health-Systems.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO Publications Bibliographic API. Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. WHO Publications Bibliographic API; 2024. https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf", "country_ids": [ "SAU" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": null, "material_id": "material:0c5899709d1153adb966d54c", "notes": [ "Verify the exact bibliographic citation against the original source.", "Confirm that the document applies to the named country and intended territorial scope.", "Confirm document type, issuing institution, authority, and claim-specific suitability.", "Retrieve and hash the exact source version when it is not already verified.", "Check publication date, effective period, currency, and supersession risk.", "Confirm only domains directly supported by the reviewed source.", "Add substantive feedback directly through the text-anchored annotation layer.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-source-triage-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "source_triage_record", "record_kind_label": "Source Triage Record", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "global_literature", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "a859cc83d11508435744f1ce4fb6f39396083c22e60bea3f872887eb2dd1863f" }, "statement": null, "tags": [], "territory": null, "title": "Saudi Arabia: a primary health care case study in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/376145/9789240084735-eng.pdf" } ] } ] }