{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "display_policy": "all_display_eligible_evidence_is_public_and_reviewable_by_annotation", "country": { "iso3": "IRL", "name": "Ireland", "aliases": [ "Ireland" ], "type": "country", "who_region": "EUR", "who_region_source": "EUR", "wb_region": "Europe & Central Asia", "income_group": "high", "first_year": 2000, "last_core_year": 2023 }, "build": { "version": "2026-08-23+6c22928b", "built_at": "2026-08-23T06:47:49Z" }, "summary": { "direct_typed_sources": 0, "direct_typed_claims": 0, "direct_typed_relationships": 0, "direct_typed_decision_rights": 0, "candidate_sources": 2, "candidate_facts": 0, "exact_contexts": 0, "source_linked_analytical_mappings": 10, "source_linked_analytical_object_rows": 14, "all_material_records": 30, "library_document_candidates": 2, "candidate_queue_records": 26, "current_public_projection_records": 2 }, "availability": [ { "domain": "actors", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "government_responsibilities", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "ownership", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 3, "exact_context_count": 2, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "decision_rights", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "autonomy", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 3, "exact_context_count": 1, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "primary_care", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 13, "exact_context_count": 4, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "hospital_organization", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 17, "exact_context_count": 7, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "referral_design", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 3, "exact_context_count": 2, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "observed_referral", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 2, "exact_context_count": 1, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "networks", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "facility_data", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "utilization", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 7, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "patient_flows", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 5, "exact_context_count": 2, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "governance", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 13, "exact_context_count": 5, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "market_structure", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 5, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "reform_history", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 10, "exact_context_count": 3, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." }, { "domain": "authoritative_review", "period_id": "current-structure", "display_status": "evidence_displayed", "material_record_count": 11, "exact_context_count": 6, "direct_typed_mapping_count": 0, "rationale": "Every matching collected material record is public and open for annotation." } ], "direct_typed_objects": { "sources": [], "claims": [], "actors": [], "relationships": [], "decision_rights": [], "provider_organizations": [], "autonomy": [], "accountability": [], "referrals": [], "patient_flows": [], "networks": [], "integration": [], "reforms": [] }, "source_linked_analytical_mappings": [ { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:actors-functions:hse-statutory-role", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "target_view": "functions", "target_slot": "hse-statutory-role", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Health Service Executive Act 2004 and Department directory", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-service-executive-act-2004", "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-aegis-bodies-2025" ], "typed_fields": { "architecture": "The Act establishes the HSE and the Department directory states that the HSE runs public health services.", "boundary": "The sources do not allocate every operational decision to named provider organisations." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "irl:hse", "label": "Health Service Executive", "family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:59c0658e318dc9150fb6c858" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236", "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:59c0658e318dc9150fb6c858" }, { "node_id": "irl:public-services", "label": "Public health services", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c8b66aad290e63a2e6366b41" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236", "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c8b66aad290e63a2e6366b41" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "irl:hse", "target_node_id": "irl:public-services", "relationship": "has stated responsibility for running", "relationship_family": "governance", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:d57d72c8e5b9b3ac30efc6f3" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236", "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:d57d72c8e5b9b3ac30efc6f3" } ] }, "title": "The HSE has a stated public-service role", "statement": "The legal and Department sources support a stated HSE role in Ireland's public health services, without asserting a complete operational authority map.", "citation": "Government of Ireland, Health Service Executive Act 2004; Department of Health, Bodies under the aegis, 2025.", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "locator": "Part 2, sections 6-7; Health Service Executive (HSE).", "period": "2004 Act and 2025 directory context", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "governance", "decision_rights" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Health Service Executive Act 2004", "citation": "Government of Ireland. Health Service Executive Act 2004 (No. 42). Irish Statute Book; 2004. https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "locator": { "locator_type": "legislation_section", "sections": [ "Part 2", "Section 6", "Section 7" ], "source_word_anchor": "Establishment day and establishment of Executive", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-service-executive-act-2004", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236" }, { "title": "Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health. Updated 28 October 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "Health Service Executive (HSE)" ], "source_word_anchor": "responsibility for running the public health services in Ireland", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "ea6fa785ceb750f37684d9dea0d88d2b22c1999141c10afc03c9a1f9ff7955e1", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-aegis-bodies-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236", "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c0749e237d08f650247cfe13", "display-claim:59c0658e318dc9150fb6c858", "display-claim:c8b66aad290e63a2e6366b41", "display-claim:d57d72c8e5b9b3ac30efc6f3" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c0749e237d08f650247cfe13", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:actors-functions:primary-care-policy-role", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "target_view": "functions", "target_slot": "primary-care-policy-role", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Department Primary Care Division page", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:primary-care-division-2020" ], "typed_fields": { "role": "The Department describes policy and implementation-oversight functions for primary care, including HSE and contracted-provider services.", "boundary": "This is not a measure of provider activity or market share." }, "analytical_objects": { "function_assignments": [ { "actor_label": "Department of Health Primary Care Division", "function_label": "Primary-care policy and implementation oversight", "role": "Stated Department function", "actor_family": "national", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:f77f799fac05459e5e4fea70" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:eb720f8ceceb66abcf88745b" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:f8be56bf0025bc147ee17b86" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:f77f799fac05459e5e4fea70" } ] }, "title": "Primary-care policy role is stated", "statement": "The Department page identifies a primary-care policy and oversight role, without converting it into a delivery-volume or referral-performance claim.", "citation": "Department of Health, Primary Care Division, 2020.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/primary-care-division/", "locator": "Primary Care Division.", "period": "Page updated 2020", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "primary_care", "market_structure" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Primary Care Division", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Primary Care Division. Updated 9 September 2020. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/primary-care-division/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/primary-care-division/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "Primary Care Division" ], "source_word_anchor": "integrated multidisciplinary care provided by the Health Service Executive", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "9c38bd62d623a91b63254e82b64ac90f61e2e77a2b63e88096a51581ba7a4062", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:primary-care-division-2020", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:eb720f8ceceb66abcf88745b", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:f8be56bf0025bc147ee17b86" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "9c38bd62d623a91b63254e82b64ac90f61e2e77a2b63e88096a51581ba7a4062", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:eb720f8ceceb66abcf88745b" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:f8be56bf0025bc147ee17b86" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:f46f6e7ef66f79b90eafe374", "display-claim:f77f799fac05459e5e4fea70" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:f46f6e7ef66f79b90eafe374", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:decision-autonomy:no-provider-autonomy-score", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "target_view": "autonomy", "target_slot": "no-provider-autonomy-score", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "HSE Health Regions and OECD profile", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025", "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023" ], "typed_fields": { "boundary": "The cited sources do not allocate provider-level financial, workforce, procurement, capital, operations, or service-mix authority." }, "analytical_objects": { "autonomy_cells": [ { "dimension": "Operations", "provider_group": "Hospitals", "authority_label": "Not determined from cited sources", "counterpart": "Regional reform descriptions and a country profile do not establish hospital operational autonomy.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:0fa05befe90de1ff70ef8cb4" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51", "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11", "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:0fa05befe90de1ff70ef8cb4" } ] }, "title": "Provider autonomy remains unclassified", "statement": "No categorical hospital or primary-care autonomy score is derived from the cited reform and review sources.", "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025; OECD and Observatory, Ireland Country Health Profile, 2023.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change; 4. The Health System.", "period": "2023 to 2025 source context", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "autonomy", "decision_rights", "hospital_organization", "primary_care" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "HSE Health Regions", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. HSE Health Regions. Updated 12 May 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures", "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change" ], "source_word_anchor": "Operational responsibility has now moved from the HSE Centre", "source_word_count": 9 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" }, { "title": "Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023", "citation": "OECD and European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023. State of Health in the EU. OECD Publishing; 2023. https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_section_anchor", "sections": [ "4. The Health System" ], "source_word_anchor": "organisation of the Irish healthcare system", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "5853a46e680914664e36c70d49f6c00c95ed0166def77352f7ce92369c19d178", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51", "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11", "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:e8fd025424a0f100065bd2b0", "display-claim:0fa05befe90de1ff70ef8cb4" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:e8fd025424a0f100065bd2b0", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:decision-autonomy:regional-operational-transfer", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "target_view": "decisions", "target_slot": "regional-operational-transfer", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Department HSE Health Regions page", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025" ], "typed_fields": { "decision_boundary": "The Department states operational responsibility moved from the HSE Centre to Health Regions and Integrated Healthcare Areas in October 2024.", "boundary": "The source does not score individual regions or providers by decision domain." }, "analytical_objects": { "decision_cells": [ { "decision_id": "irl-regional-operations", "decision_label": "Regional operational responsibility", "actor_label": "HSE Health Regions and Integrated Healthcare Areas", "actor_family": "subnational", "role": "Stated transfer of operational responsibility", "constraint": "No complete financial, workforce, procurement, capital, or service-mix decision matrix is established.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:98fc901b62ec768494667545" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:98fc901b62ec768494667545" } ] }, "title": "Regional responsibility is described, autonomy is not scored", "statement": "The reform page identifies a transfer of operational responsibility but does not establish a categorical autonomy score for a region, hospital, or primary-care provider.", "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change.", "period": "Regions commenced 2024; page updated 2025", "territory": "Ireland, six HSE Health Regions", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "decision_rights", "autonomy", "governance", "reform_history" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "HSE Health Regions", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. HSE Health Regions. Updated 12 May 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures", "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change" ], "source_word_anchor": "Operational responsibility has now moved from the HSE Centre", "source_word_count": 9 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:3dbf6b1fd3e47eb0b8c77dc9", "display-claim:98fc901b62ec768494667545" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:3dbf6b1fd3e47eb0b8c77dc9", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:delivery-referrals:public-acute-activity-scope", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "referrals", "target_slot": "public-acute-activity-scope", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Health in Ireland hospital-care series", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-in-ireland-hospital-care-2026" ], "typed_fields": { "observed_measure": "The Department's series reports specified public acute-hospital beds, inpatient discharges and emergency-department activity through 2024.", "boundary": "It is not an observed referral-completion, bypassing, or all-provider patient-flow measure." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "Public acute-hospital activity series", "observation": "Beds, discharges and emergency-department activity reported with stated scope and exclusions", "scope": "Ireland, public acute hospitals, 2015 to 2024", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:85e23192f564f4984d26780b" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:95208c6dfbc39a363def8796" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:1b05d50ba925aeb84138feae" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:85e23192f564f4984d26780b" } ] }, "title": "Observed acute activity does not establish referral completion", "statement": "Observed public acute-hospital activity is displayed with its scope, without inferring a national referral pathway or a public-private utilisation share.", "citation": "Department of Health, Health in Ireland: Key Trends - Hospital care, 2026.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/health-in-ireland-key-trends-hospital-care/", "locator": "Acute hospital activity, Table 3.1.", "period": "2015 to 2024 series, published 2026", "territory": "Ireland, stated public acute-hospital scope", "evidence_mode_candidate": "observed", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "observed_referral", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "hospital_organization" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Health in Ireland: Key Trends - Hospital care", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Health in Ireland: Key Trends - Hospital care. Published 17 May 2026. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/health-in-ireland-key-trends-hospital-care/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/health-in-ireland-key-trends-hospital-care/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_table", "sections": [ "Acute hospital activity", "Table 3.1" ], "source_word_anchor": "Public acute hospital summary statistics, 2015-2024", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cfe0ace28b47918934db2de402c9288b8cda3534b17fcd86cd6bc60e3e395b17", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-in-ireland-hospital-care-2026", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:95208c6dfbc39a363def8796", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:1b05d50ba925aeb84138feae" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "cfe0ace28b47918934db2de402c9288b8cda3534b17fcd86cd6bc60e3e395b17", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:95208c6dfbc39a363def8796" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:1b05d50ba925aeb84138feae" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:ec96509458fbf72d800b82b5", "display-claim:85e23192f564f4984d26780b" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:ec96509458fbf72d800b82b5", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:delivery-referrals:reported-system-profile-context", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "target_view": "delivery", "target_slot": "reported-system-profile-context", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "OECD and Observatory profile, ESRI research, and Parliamentary Budget Office projections", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "country-improvement-source:IRL:esri-healthcare-demand-workforce-2024", "country-improvement-source:IRL:parliamentary-budget-office-workforce-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "delivery": "The profile, ESRI research, and Parliamentary Budget Office report supply bounded reported context on organisation, demand, workforce, and service delivery.", "boundary": "These sources do not substitute for a current facility-level service map or a verified referral-flow series." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_delivery_observations": [ { "label": "Reported country delivery context", "observation": "Policy profile, primary and acute-care research, and public-system workforce projections", "scope": "Ireland, 2023 to 2024 sources; not an observed service-flow record", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:94196f281740667e225a2363" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "display-source:IRL:f56705fbe6fd49e54f2ac916", "display-source:IRL:9abb55700a6400c043f27991" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85", "display-source-version:3be2254aa751d52b8fad38d0", "display-source-version:a01a0b4cd2454fb8ce694eec" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:94196f281740667e225a2363" } ] }, "title": "Reported system context is distinct from observed flow data", "statement": "The OECD and Observatory profile, ESRI research, and Parliamentary Budget Office projections are retained as reported context and not converted into a current patient-pathway measure.", "citation": "OECD and European Observatory, Ireland Country Health Profile 2023; Humes, Barrett and Walsh, ESRI Research Series 181, 2024; Parliamentary Budget Office, 2024.", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "locator": "4. The Health System; ESRI Research Series 181, abstract; Parliamentary Budget Office Key Messages, page 7.", "period": "2023 profile and 2024 research/projections", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "authoritative_review" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023", "citation": "OECD and European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023. State of Health in the EU. OECD Publishing; 2023. https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_section_anchor", "sections": [ "4. The Health System" ], "source_word_anchor": "organisation of the Irish healthcare system", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "5853a46e680914664e36c70d49f6c00c95ed0166def77352f7ce92369c19d178", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85" }, { "title": "Effects of new residential developments on local healthcare demand and workforce", "citation": "Humes H, Barrett M, Walsh B. Effects of new residential developments on local healthcare demand and workforce: evidence from primary and acute public hospital care in Ireland. ESRI Research Series 181; 2024. https://www.esri.ie/publications/effects-of-new-residential-developments-on-local-healthcare-demand-and-workforce", "url": "https://www.esri.ie/publications/effects-of-new-residential-developments-on-local-healthcare-demand-and-workforce", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_title_and_abstract", "sections": [ "ESRI Research Series 181", "Abstract" ], "source_word_anchor": "evidence from primary and acute public hospital care", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "085bd5d1133bb762d172c225d1107b864d1d270996a353d440877635d54494bb", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:esri-healthcare-demand-workforce-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:f56705fbe6fd49e54f2ac916", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:3be2254aa751d52b8fad38d0" }, { "title": "Cost and Workforce Projections of Non-Consultant Hospital Doctors and Consultants", "citation": "Parliamentary Budget Office, Houses of the Oireachtas. Cost and Workforce Projections of Non-Consultant Hospital Doctors and Consultants in a Consultant-Delivered Health Service. Publication 26 of 2024. https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/parliamentaryBudgetOffice/2024/2024-06-21_cost-and-workforce-projections-of-non-consultant-hospital-doctors-and-consultants-in-a-consultant-delivered-health-service_en.pdf", "url": "https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/parliamentaryBudgetOffice/2024/2024-06-21_cost-and-workforce-projections-of-non-consultant-hospital-doctors-and-consultants-in-a-consultant-delivered-health-service_en.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_and_section", "sections": [ "Key Messages", "Page 7" ], "source_word_anchor": "This paper projects likely demand for and supply", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "2fc50ae1e7ab34d7649c7b61e129cccc6cdf426ae684a86eb05e93ec77ac8fdd", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:parliamentary-budget-office-workforce-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:9abb55700a6400c043f27991", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:a01a0b4cd2454fb8ce694eec" } ], "source_version": { "file_sha256": "5853a46e680914664e36c70d49f6c00c95ed0166def77352f7ce92369c19d178", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "display-source:IRL:f56705fbe6fd49e54f2ac916", "display-source:IRL:9abb55700a6400c043f27991" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85", "display-source-version:3be2254aa751d52b8fad38d0", "display-source-version:a01a0b4cd2454fb8ce694eec" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:13ebdda4d4a75fa7e53ea930", "display-claim:94196f281740667e225a2363" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:13ebdda4d4a75fa7e53ea930", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:relationships-networks:regional-integration-design", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "target_view": "referrals", "target_slot": "regional-integration-design", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Department HSE Health Regions page", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025" ], "typed_fields": { "relationship": "Health Regions are intended to align hospital and community healthcare geographically for integrated care.", "boundary": "The stated design is not observed evidence of referral completion, bypassing, or counter-referral." }, "analytical_objects": { "graph_nodes": [ { "node_id": "irl:regions", "label": "HSE Health Regions", "family": "subnational", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:0a4672b1c8efa2d62cb28e45" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:0a4672b1c8efa2d62cb28e45" }, { "node_id": "irl:community-acute", "label": "Community and acute services", "family": "provider", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:1343cb266dd10005b187aa90" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:1343cb266dd10005b187aa90" } ], "graph_edges": [ { "source_node_id": "irl:regions", "target_node_id": "irl:community-acute", "relationship": "are intended to align", "relationship_family": "network", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:8eec5e160abd427dd2ffa2c6" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:8eec5e160abd427dd2ffa2c6" } ] }, "title": "Regional integration is a stated organisational design", "statement": "The Department describes an integrated regional design, without treating the design as proof of observed patient movement.", "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures.", "period": "2024 to 2025 reform context", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "networks", "referral_design", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "hospital_organization" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "HSE Health Regions", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. HSE Health Regions. Updated 12 May 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures", "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change" ], "source_word_anchor": "Operational responsibility has now moved from the HSE Centre", "source_word_count": 9 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:fe9b099f6228d7d9e1eded01", "display-claim:0a4672b1c8efa2d62cb28e45", "display-claim:1343cb266dd10005b187aa90", "display-claim:8eec5e160abd427dd2ffa2c6" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:fe9b099f6228d7d9e1eded01", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:relationships-networks:statutory-bodies-not-ownership-share", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "target_view": "public-private", "target_slot": "statutory-bodies-not-ownership-share", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Department bodies-under-aegis directory and IMO annual report", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-aegis-bodies-2025", "country-improvement-source:IRL:imo-annual-report-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "ownership_boundary": "The directory identifies public statutory bodies and the IMO report presents a professional perspective on capacity, but neither supplies a denominator for public-private provider composition." }, "analytical_objects": { "provider_organizations": [ { "label": "Departmental statutory bodies and the HSE", "ownership": "Public statutory organisational categories; no sector share inferred", "scope": "Department directory, updated 2025; IMO annual report is not used as a sector denominator", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c442d7b4c51a327a5a43c137" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9", "display-source:IRL:a1c66fc892f75a1ec456354a" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151", "display-source-version:081d0684db2b31bd8653366e" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c442d7b4c51a327a5a43c137" } ] }, "title": "Public statutory bodies are visible, not a sector share", "statement": "The Department directory identifies public organisations and the IMO report presents a stated capacity perspective, while facility, bed, activity, workforce, and spending shares remain unclassified.", "citation": "Department of Health, Bodies under the aegis, 2025; Irish Medical Organisation, Annual Report 2024.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/", "locator": "Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health; Health Service Executive (HSE); IMO President's report, page 5.", "period": "IMO report 2024; directory updated 2025", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "ownership", "market_structure", "actors", "hospital_organization", "networks" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health. Updated 28 October 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "Health Service Executive (HSE)" ], "source_word_anchor": "responsibility for running the public health services in Ireland", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "ea6fa785ceb750f37684d9dea0d88d2b22c1999141c10afc03c9a1f9ff7955e1", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-aegis-bodies-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151" }, { "title": "Irish Medical Organisation Annual Report 2024", "citation": "Irish Medical Organisation. Annual Report 2024. 2024. https://www.imo.ie/about-imo/annual-reports/annual-report-2024-1/IMO-Annual-Report-2024-final.pdf", "url": "https://www.imo.ie/about-imo/annual-reports/annual-report-2024-1/IMO-Annual-Report-2024-final.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_and_section", "sections": [ "President's report", "Page 5" ], "source_word_anchor": "HSE to blame doctors for long waiting lists", "source_word_count": 8 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "0c4fd90260d75c1e77072e24ef5cf8248848ee60a40ec14924f13902d926b60c", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:imo-annual-report-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:a1c66fc892f75a1ec456354a", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:081d0684db2b31bd8653366e" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "ea6fa785ceb750f37684d9dea0d88d2b22c1999141c10afc03c9a1f9ff7955e1", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:11ec1b8d52baecf5598f6ee9", "display-source:IRL:a1c66fc892f75a1ec456354a" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:1626a54e2230b2347e93e151", "display-source-version:081d0684db2b31bd8653366e" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:60f5a505f50625d337486e9b", "display-claim:c442d7b4c51a327a5a43c137" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:60f5a505f50625d337486e9b", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:time-reform:health-regions-implementation", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "target_view": "reforms", "target_slot": "health-regions-implementation", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "Department HSE Health Regions page", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025" ], "typed_fields": { "reform_event": "Six Health Regions commenced in March 2024, with the management structure replacing CHO and Hospital Group structures in October 2024.", "boundary": "The source does not demonstrate the implementation effect on access, integration, decision quality, or outcomes." }, "analytical_objects": { "reform_events": [ { "event_id": "irl-health-regions-2024", "label": "HSE Health Regions implementation", "year": 2024, "status": "Formal implementation milestone; effects not established by this source.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:8238920d803a05515e5af681" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:8238920d803a05515e5af681" } ] }, "title": "Health-regions reform has bounded implementation milestones", "statement": "The regional reform is recorded with its stated dates, without treating those dates as evidence of achieved integration or outcomes.", "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025.", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures; HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change.", "period": "March and October 2024 milestones; page updated 2025", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "formal", "verification_source_layer": "official", "coverage_domains": [ "reform_history", "governance", "networks", "hospital_organization", "primary_care" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "HSE Health Regions", "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. HSE Health Regions. Updated 12 May 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "sections": [ "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures", "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change" ], "source_word_anchor": "Operational responsibility has now moved from the HSE Centre", "source_word_count": 9 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:73aba2ad9de360f8ba7eeb51" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:85436c13d31d961c08a8ed11" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:ac5dc3dcb9f83613561cfd63", "display-claim:8238920d803a05515e5af681" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:ac5dc3dcb9f83613561cfd63", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" }, { "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:time-reform:historical-and-current-source-boundary", "country_id": "IRL", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "target_view": "reforms", "target_slot": "historical-and-current-source-boundary", "support_state": "candidate_supported", "annotation_state": "open", "mapping_basis": "2004 Act, 2023 Country Health Profile, and 2024 qualitative research", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-service-executive-act-2004", "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "country-improvement-source:IRL:farsaci-health-policy-2024" ], "typed_fields": { "time_boundary": "The 2004 Act is formal establishment context, the 2023 profile is a dated synthesis, and the 2024 study interprets earlier shocks; none alone establishes all current post-2024 arrangements.", "boundary": "No supersession or implementation inference is made beyond the cited source periods." }, "analytical_objects": { "reform_events": [ { "event_id": "irl-hse-establishment-context", "label": "HSE statutory establishment context", "year": 2004, "status": "Formal establishment source; current arrangements require current-source checking.", "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:81bcd5ec79fa09272342e305" ], "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "display-source:IRL:0b5375898933f322853debbe" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236", "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85", "display-source-version:8607cde29f91859b0a07f1c2" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:81bcd5ec79fa09272342e305" } ] }, "title": "Formal establishment and reported review context remain time-bounded", "statement": "The wave keeps legal establishment, later review, and qualitative shock research separate from claims about current reform implementation.", "citation": "Government of Ireland, Health Service Executive Act 2004; OECD and European Observatory, Ireland Country Health Profile 2023; Farsaci et al., Health Policy, 2024.", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "locator": "Part 2, sections 6-7; 4. The Health System; PubMed PMID 38583364, Abstract.", "period": "2004 Act, 2023 profile, and 2008 to COVID-19 research context", "territory": "Ireland", "evidence_mode_candidate": "reported", "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "reform_history", "authoritative_review", "governance", "decision_rights" ], "source_references": [ { "title": "Health Service Executive Act 2004", "citation": "Government of Ireland. Health Service Executive Act 2004 (No. 42). Irish Statute Book; 2004. https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "locator": { "locator_type": "legislation_section", "sections": [ "Part 2", "Section 6", "Section 7" ], "source_word_anchor": "Establishment day and establishment of Executive", "source_word_count": 6 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-service-executive-act-2004", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236" }, { "title": "Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023", "citation": "OECD and European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023. State of Health in the EU. OECD Publishing; 2023. https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_section_anchor", "sections": [ "4. The Health System" ], "source_word_anchor": "organisation of the Irish healthcare system", "source_word_count": 5 }, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "5853a46e680914664e36c70d49f6c00c95ed0166def77352f7ce92369c19d178", "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85" }, { "title": "Understanding the legacies of shocks on health system performance", "citation": "Farsaci L, Fleming P, Almirall-Sanchez A, O'Donoghue C, Thomas S. Understanding the legacies of shocks on health system performance: Exploring Ireland's management of recent crises and its implications for policy. Health Policy. 2024;143:105063. https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/efetch.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38583364&rettype=abstract&retmode=xml", "url": "https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/efetch.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38583364&rettype=abstract&retmode=xml", "locator": { "locator_type": "database_record_and_abstract", "sections": [ "PMID 38583364", "Abstract" ], "source_word_anchor": "Irish experience of the 2008 economic crisis and the Covid-19 pandemic", "source_word_count": 11 }, "source_version": { "response_sha256": "32386588af6e7f8cfde6dcc044f192a37f0491d74e23dc8075be4f73a0e57a6c", "detected_media_type": "application/xml", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-22" }, "source_projection_id": "country-improvement-source:IRL:farsaci-health-policy-2024", "display_source_id": "display-source:IRL:0b5375898933f322853debbe", "source_version_id": "display-source-version:8607cde29f91859b0a07f1c2" } ], "source_version": { "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2", "detected_media_type": "text/html", "hash_verified": true, "retrieved_at": "2026-08-21" }, "display_source_ids": [ "display-source:IRL:5d326645b1c306e328ff77ca", "display-source:IRL:c5c095f1deae3e2432940903", "display-source:IRL:0b5375898933f322853debbe" ], "source_version_ids": [ "display-source-version:cdc60bfc8f6a03e536010236", "display-source-version:8b10dc7e8b24f8550b438b85", "display-source-version:8607cde29f91859b0a07f1c2" ], "display_claim_ids": [ "display-claim:c994eb425762343ae82b1993", "display-claim:81bcd5ec79fa09272342e305" ], "display_evidence_object_id": "display-claim:c994eb425762343ae82b1993", "display_eligible": true, "canonical_claim": false, "publication_boundary": "source_linked_typed_mapping_visible_for_annotation_not_a_canonical_claim" } ], "displayed_evidence": { "candidate_sources": [ { "candidate_source_id": "candidate-source:IRL:7ac82fd4304397bb5107", "evidence_layer": "candidate_corpus_page_locator", "evidence_layers": [ "candidate_corpus_page_locator" ], "source_layers": [ "candidate_corpus_page_locator" ], "source_type": "candidate corpus source", "display_eligible": true, "title": "EU investment grants review", "citation": "EU investment grants review. 1999. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf", "citation_string": "EU investment grants review. 1999. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf", "citation_status": "machine_formatted_from_title_year_url", "citation_provenance": "machine formatted from source title, publication year, and URL", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf", "publication_year": 1999, "source_families": [ "global_corpus" ], "channels": [ "corpus_excerpt_queue" ], "verification_source_layer": "grey_literature", "coverage_domains": [], "url_verification_status": null, "source_version": { "file_sha256": "31ba94972300f42af2847d9d5c4020bb079b9799ab008af96c34af2766a131ba", "text_sha256": "4ffb57b65b8c9a13f47c052e0faff0e502769362aeceffc26072b6ba611769aa", "response_sha256": null, "page_count": null }, "locator": { "physical_pdf_page": 2, "source_word_anchor": "Barker Tenenbaum and Woolf Governance and Regulation of Power Pools and System" }, "display_status": "shown_in_full", "review_channel": "text_anchored_annotation", "verification_requirements": [] }, { "candidate_source_id": "candidate-source:IRL:eaa3ac8c7969e140414b", "evidence_layer": "candidate_source_metadata", "evidence_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata" ], "source_type": "candidate source metadata", "display_eligible": true, "title": "Ireland: health system review 2009", "citation": "WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: health system review 2009. 2009. https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "citation_string": "WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: health system review 2009. 2009. https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "citation_status": "supplied", "citation_provenance": "source metadata", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "publication_year": 2009, "source_families": [ "global_health_systems_library_health_system_review", "regional_systems" ], "channels": [ "curated_review", "grey_library" ], "verification_source_layer": "review_literature", "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "url_verification_status": null, "source_version": { "file_sha256": null, "text_sha256": null, "response_sha256": null, "page_count": null }, "locator": null, "display_status": "shown_in_full", "review_channel": "text_anchored_annotation", "verification_requirements": [] } ], "candidate_facts": [], "exact_contexts": [] }, "evidence_scorecard": { "country_id": "IRL", "audit_passed": true, "preparation_stage": "direct_typed_mapping", "preparation_stage_label": "Explicit analytical mappings", "scores": { "analytical_mapping_groups": { "denominator": 5, "numerator": 5, "score": 100, "unit": "explicit analytical object groups" }, "controlled_domain_leads": { "denominator": 17, "numerator": 17, "score": 100, "unit": "controlled domains with displayed candidate leads" }, "material_locator_coverage": { "denominator": 30, "numerator": 26, "score": 87, "unit": "material records with an exact locator" }, "material_url_coverage": { "denominator": 30, "numerator": 30, "score": 100, "unit": "material records with at least one public URL" }, "material_version_coverage": { "denominator": 30, "numerator": 27, "score": 90, "unit": "material records with an immutable source version" }, "source_layer_presence": { "denominator": 3, "numerator": 3, "score": 100, "unit": "displayed candidate-source layers" } }, "represented_domain_ids": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "missing_domain_ids": [], "direct_typed_domain_ids": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "ownership", "decision_rights", "autonomy", "primary_care", "hospital_organization", "referral_design", "observed_referral", "networks", "facility_data", "utilization", "patient_flows", "governance", "market_structure", "reform_history", "authoritative_review" ], "priority_actions": [ { "action_id": "capture-source-versions", "detail": "3 of 30 displayed materials do not yet carry a source-version field.", "label": "Capture immutable source versions" } ], "review_ready_material_ids": [ "material:e249f7275633420589d3528b", "material:d3244312b69550a221f904dc", "material:d070dfa0e632592663a33ef4", "material:b5e73c329546621977825c87", "material:93fea48ea09f370f1f41ad13" ], "full_scorecard_url": "https://wb-works.site/tools/health-organization/data/evidence-scorecards.json" }, "materials": [ { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 60, "text_words": 20926 }, "citation": "A bundle of joy or an expensive luxury : a comparative analysis of the economic environment for family formation in Western Europe. 1999. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "BEL", "DEU", "DNK", "ESP", "FIN", "FRA", "GBR", "GRC", "IRL", "ITA", "LUX", "NLD", "PRT", "SWE" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "working paper", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:00648d213c3c8ffc7e0ed10e", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "1999-01-31", "publication_year": 1999, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "d8365c5e91564cecc786910060a46fe5aec220d25a007c665c2db8c7390e7289", "page_count": 60, "text_sha256": "4fd45dd556a5d8506b1b44f088225daaec31fcc502581c3df91913898c29c8ef" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization" ], "territory": "national", "title": "A bundle of joy or an expensive luxury : a comparative analysis of the economic environment for family formation in Western Europe", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/320561468761049482/pdf/multi-page.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/320561468761049482" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/320561468761049482/pdf/multi-page.pdf" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/320561468761049482/text/multi-page.txt" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "download_status": "Downloaded successfully", "downloaded": true, "extracted": true, "source_bytes_verified": true, "text_pages": 52, "text_words": 23601 }, "citation": "EU investment grants review. 1999. https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds", "country_ids": [ "ESP", "GBR", "IRL", "SWE" ], "coverage_domains": [ "leadership_governance" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "unknown", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 2, "source_word_anchor": "and Worzala Improving Women's Health Services in the Russian Federation Results of", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:df852754f26fca62b58ce8b0", "notes": [ "Machine-tagged Organization candidate. Relevance, jurisdiction, and claim support remain open to annotation.", "Immutable corpus file and extracted-text hashes are linked to this document.", "A machine-validated physical-page locator is linked to this document for annotation." ], "origin": "global-health-systems-library", "period": null, "publication_date": "1999-09-30", "publication_year": 1999, "record_kind": "library_document_candidate", "record_kind_label": "Library document candidate", "screening": { "corpus_retrieval_verified": true, "evidence_work_review_state": "auto", "machine_screening_reason": null, "machine_screening_state": "organization_tag_candidate", "organization_tag_confidence": 0.85, "page_anchor_linked": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected_unless_selected" }, "source_layers": [ "global_literature" ], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "31ba94972300f42af2847d9d5c4020bb079b9799ab008af96c34af2766a131ba", "page_count": 52, "text_sha256": "4ffb57b65b8c9a13f47c052e0faff0e502769362aeceffc26072b6ba611769aa" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "who_building_block:leadership_governance" ], "territory": "national", "title": "EU investment grants review", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://search.worldbank.org/api/v3/wds" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/text/multi-page.txt" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "World Bank Documents and Reports", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "2004 Act, 2023 Country Health Profile, and 2024 qualitative research", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:time-reform:historical-and-current-source-boundary", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-service-executive-act-2004", "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "country-improvement-source:IRL:farsaci-health-policy-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "historical-and-current-source-boundary", "target_view": "reforms", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "No supersession or implementation inference is made beyond the cited source periods.", "time_boundary": "The 2004 Act is formal establishment context, the 2023 profile is a dated synthesis, and the 2024 study interprets earlier shocks; none alone establishes all current post-2024 arrangements." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Government of Ireland, Health Service Executive Act 2004; OECD and European Observatory, Ireland Country Health Profile 2023; Farsaci et al., Health Policy, 2024.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Part 2, sections 6-7; 4. The Health System; PubMed PMID 38583364, Abstract." }, "material_id": "material:eee484ef004380254176fe54", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2004 Act, 2023 profile, and 2008 to COVID-19 research context", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2" }, "statement": "The wave keeps legal establishment, later review, and qualitative shock research separate from claims about current reform implementation.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Formal establishment and reported review context remain time-bounded", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Understanding the legacies of shocks on health system performance", "url": "https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/efetch.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38583364&rettype=abstract&retmode=xml" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Department HSE Health Regions page", "mapping_group": "time_and_reform", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:time-reform:health-regions-implementation", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "health-regions-implementation", "target_view": "reforms", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "The source does not demonstrate the implementation effect on access, integration, decision quality, or outcomes.", "reform_event": "Six Health Regions commenced in March 2024, with the management structure replacing CHO and Hospital Group structures in October 2024." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "governance", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures; HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change." }, "material_id": "material:32d21203d3b07ec2ac8a1024", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "March and October 2024 milestones; page updated 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2" }, "statement": "The regional reform is recorded with its stated dates, without treating those dates as evidence of achieved integration or outcomes.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Health-regions reform has bounded implementation milestones", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Health in Ireland hospital-care series", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:delivery-referrals:public-acute-activity-scope", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-in-ireland-hospital-care-2026" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "public-acute-activity-scope", "target_view": "referrals", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "It is not an observed referral-completion, bypassing, or all-provider patient-flow measure.", "observed_measure": "The Department's series reports specified public acute-hospital beds, inpatient discharges and emergency-department activity through 2024." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Health in Ireland: Key Trends - Hospital care, 2026.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Acute hospital activity, Table 3.1." }, "material_id": "material:0949e939997611bd045e1fb7", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2015 to 2024 series, published 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cfe0ace28b47918934db2de402c9288b8cda3534b17fcd86cd6bc60e3e395b17" }, "statement": "Observed public acute-hospital activity is displayed with its scope, without inferring a national referral pathway or a public-private utilisation share.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland, stated public acute-hospital scope", "title": "Observed acute activity does not establish referral completion", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/health-in-ireland-key-trends-hospital-care/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Department Primary Care Division page", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:actors-functions:primary-care-policy-role", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:primary-care-division-2020" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "primary-care-policy-role", "target_view": "functions", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "This is not a measure of provider activity or market share.", "role": "The Department describes policy and implementation-oversight functions for primary care, including HSE and contracted-provider services." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Primary Care Division, 2020.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "government_responsibilities", "market_structure", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Primary Care Division." }, "material_id": "material:6bc347f8f7a9e572c657c8d7", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Page updated 2020", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "9c38bd62d623a91b63254e82b64ac90f61e2e77a2b63e88096a51581ba7a4062" }, "statement": "The Department page identifies a primary-care policy and oversight role, without converting it into a delivery-volume or referral-performance claim.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Primary-care policy role is stated", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/primary-care-division/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "HSE Health Regions and OECD profile", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:decision-autonomy:no-provider-autonomy-score", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025", "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "no-provider-autonomy-score", "target_view": "autonomy", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "The cited sources do not allocate provider-level financial, workforce, procurement, capital, operations, or service-mix authority." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025; OECD and Observatory, Ireland Country Health Profile, 2023.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "autonomy", "decision_rights", "hospital_organization", "primary_care" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change; 4. The Health System." }, "material_id": "material:6e84e274da41335d74a8e3d0", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2023 to 2025 source context", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2" }, "statement": "No categorical hospital or primary-care autonomy score is derived from the cited reform and review sources.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Provider autonomy remains unclassified", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Department bodies-under-aegis directory and IMO annual report", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:relationships-networks:statutory-bodies-not-ownership-share", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-aegis-bodies-2025", "country-improvement-source:IRL:imo-annual-report-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "statutory-bodies-not-ownership-share", "target_view": "public-private", "typed_fields": { "ownership_boundary": "The directory identifies public statutory bodies and the IMO report presents a professional perspective on capacity, but neither supplies a denominator for public-private provider composition." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Bodies under the aegis, 2025; Irish Medical Organisation, Annual Report 2024.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health; Health Service Executive (HSE); IMO President's report, page 5." }, "material_id": "material:1b23025fd072ababcd68dc14", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "IMO report 2024; directory updated 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "ea6fa785ceb750f37684d9dea0d88d2b22c1999141c10afc03c9a1f9ff7955e1" }, "statement": "The Department directory identifies public organisations and the IMO report presents a stated capacity perspective, while facility, bed, activity, workforce, and spending shares remain unclassified.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Public statutory bodies are visible, not a sector share", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Irish Medical Organisation Annual Report 2024", "url": "https://www.imo.ie/about-imo/annual-reports/annual-report-2024-1/IMO-Annual-Report-2024-final.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Department HSE Health Regions page", "mapping_group": "relationships_and_networks", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:relationships-networks:regional-integration-design", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "regional-integration-design", "target_view": "referrals", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "The stated design is not observed evidence of referral completion, bypassing, or counter-referral.", "relationship": "Health Regions are intended to align hospital and community healthcare geographically for integrated care." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "hospital_organization", "networks", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "SláinteCare Healthcare Delivery Structures." }, "material_id": "material:7865522f6273be130afe05e9", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2024 to 2025 reform context", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2" }, "statement": "The Department describes an integrated regional design, without treating the design as proof of observed patient movement.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Regional integration is a stated organisational design", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Department HSE Health Regions page", "mapping_group": "decision_rights_and_autonomy", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:decision-autonomy:regional-operational-transfer", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-health-regions-2025" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "regional-operational-transfer", "target_view": "decisions", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "The source does not score individual regions or providers by decision domain.", "decision_boundary": "The Department states operational responsibility moved from the HSE Centre to Health Regions and Integrated Healthcare Areas in October 2024." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, HSE Health Regions, 2025.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "HSE Health Regions: A Case for Change." }, "material_id": "material:54807385c72b2c30f716e814", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "Regions commenced 2024; page updated 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2" }, "statement": "The reform page identifies a transfer of operational responsibility but does not establish a categorical autonomy score for a region, hospital, or primary-care provider.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland, six HSE Health Regions", "title": "Regional responsibility is described, autonomy is not scored", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "OECD and Observatory profile, ESRI research, and Parliamentary Budget Office projections", "mapping_group": "delivery_and_referrals", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:delivery-referrals:reported-system-profile-context", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:oecd-country-health-profile-2023", "country-improvement-source:IRL:esri-healthcare-demand-workforce-2024", "country-improvement-source:IRL:parliamentary-budget-office-workforce-2024" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "reported-system-profile-context", "target_view": "delivery", "typed_fields": { "boundary": "These sources do not substitute for a current facility-level service map or a verified referral-flow series.", "delivery": "The profile, ESRI research, and Parliamentary Budget Office report supply bounded reported context on organisation, demand, workforce, and service delivery." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "OECD and European Observatory, Ireland Country Health Profile 2023; Humes, Barrett and Walsh, ESRI Research Series 181, 2024; Parliamentary Budget Office, 2024.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "4. The Health System; ESRI Research Series 181, abstract; Parliamentary Budget Office Key Messages, page 7." }, "material_id": "material:487eb17ece48f5c5d035e953", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2023 profile and 2024 research/projections", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "5853a46e680914664e36c70d49f6c00c95ed0166def77352f7ce92369c19d178" }, "statement": "The OECD and Observatory profile, ESRI research, and Parliamentary Budget Office projections are retained as reported context and not converted into a current patient-pathway measure.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Reported system context is distinct from observed flow data", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Effects of new residential developments on local healthcare demand and workforce", "url": "https://www.esri.ie/publications/effects-of-new-residential-developments-on-local-healthcare-demand-and-workforce" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Cost and Workforce Projections of Non-Consultant Hospital Doctors and Consultants", "url": "https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/parliamentaryBudgetOffice/2024/2024-06-21_cost-and-workforce-projections-of-non-consultant-hospital-doctors-and-consultants-in-a-consultant-delivered-health-service_en.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": { "mapping_basis": "Health Service Executive Act 2004 and Department directory", "mapping_group": "actors_and_functions", "mapping_id": "candidate-mapping:IRL:actors-functions:hse-statutory-role", "source_projection_ids": [ "country-improvement-source:IRL:health-service-executive-act-2004", "country-improvement-source:IRL:department-aegis-bodies-2025" ], "support_state": "candidate_supported", "target_slot": "hse-statutory-role", "target_view": "functions", "typed_fields": { "architecture": "The Act establishes the HSE and the Department directory states that the HSE runs public health services.", "boundary": "The sources do not allocate every operational decision to named provider organisations." } }, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Government of Ireland, Health Service Executive Act 2004; Department of Health, Bodies under the aegis, 2025.", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "description": "Part 2, sections 6-7; Health Service Executive (HSE)." }, "material_id": "material:48f4dcd20d4fbe0ad13cc40a", "notes": [], "origin": "candidate-analytical-mappings", "period": "2004 Act and 2025 directory context", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": null, "record_kind": "candidate_analytical_mapping", "record_kind_label": "Candidate Analytical Mapping", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2" }, "statement": "The legal and Department sources support a stated HSE role in Ireland's public health services, without asserting a complete operational authority map.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "The HSE has a stated public-service role", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html" }, { "kind": "source_reference", "source": "Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "EU investment grants review. 1999. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": "Barker Tenenbaum and Woolf Governance and Regulation of Power Pools and System", "institution": null, "locator": { "physical_pdf_page": 2, "source_word_anchor": "Barker Tenenbaum and Woolf Governance and Regulation of Power Pools and System", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:859451a468ccb95339354f8a", "notes": [], "origin": "global-corpus-excerpt-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 1999, "record_kind": "corpus_page_anchor", "record_kind_label": "Corpus Page Anchor", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "31ba94972300f42af2847d9d5c4020bb079b9799ab008af96c34af2766a131ba", "page_count": 52, "text_sha256": "4ffb57b65b8c9a13f47c052e0faff0e502769362aeceffc26072b6ba611769aa" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "control_knob:organization", "language:en", "source:World Bank Documents and Reports", "source_layer:global_literature" ], "territory": null, "title": "EU investment grants review", "urls": [ { "kind": "stable_source_url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health. Updated 28 October 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "responsibility for running the public health services in Ireland", "institution": "Department of Health, Ireland", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "source_word_anchor": "responsibility for running the public health services in Ireland", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:7f473b8bd2783059e535c5f2", "notes": [ "An organisational directory is not a denominator for public-private facility, bed, workforce, visit, admission, or expenditure shares." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Department page updated 28 October 2025", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2025, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "ea6fa785ceb750f37684d9dea0d88d2b22c1999141c10afc03c9a1f9ff7955e1" }, "statement": "The Department's directory identifies the HSE, HIQA, the National Treatment Purchase Fund and other statutory bodies, while describing the HSE as responsible for running public health services.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Bodies under the aegis of the Department of Health", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/bodies-under-the-aegis-of-the-department-of-health/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Parliamentary Budget Office, Houses of the Oireachtas. Cost and Workforce Projections of Non-Consultant Hospital Doctors and Consultants in a Consultant-Delivered Health Service. Publication 26 of 2024. https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/parliamentaryBudgetOffice/2024/2024-06-21_cost-and-workforce-projections-of-non-consultant-hospital-doctors-and-consultants-in-a-consultant-delivered-health-service_en.pdf", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "This paper projects likely demand for and supply", "institution": "Parliamentary Budget Office, Houses of the Oireachtas", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_and_section", "source_word_anchor": "This paper projects likely demand for and supply", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:4f8fb74472ab604784bb0547", "notes": [ "The report's projections do not establish actual staffing, provider autonomy, ownership shares, or patient-flow performance." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Demand and supply projections for 2024 to 2042; published 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "grey_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "2fc50ae1e7ab34d7649c7b61e129cccc6cdf426ae684a86eb05e93ec77ac8fdd" }, "statement": "The Parliamentary Budget Office projects demand for and supply of non-consultant hospital doctors and consultants, without establishing actual staffing or hospital autonomy.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland, public health system", "title": "Cost and Workforce Projections of Non-Consultant Hospital Doctors and Consultants", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/parliamentaryBudgetOffice/2024/2024-06-21_cost-and-workforce-projections-of-non-consultant-hospital-doctors-and-consultants-in-a-consultant-delivered-health-service_en.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Humes H, Barrett M, Walsh B. Effects of new residential developments on local healthcare demand and workforce: evidence from primary and acute public hospital care in Ireland. ESRI Research Series 181; 2024. https://www.esri.ie/publications/effects-of-new-residential-developments-on-local-healthcare-demand-and-workforce", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "primary_care", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "evidence from primary and acute public hospital care", "institution": "Economic and Social Research Institute", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_title_and_abstract", "source_word_anchor": "evidence from primary and acute public hospital care", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:d070dfa0e632592663a33ef4", "notes": [ "Do not turn the report's contextual findings into a national referral-completion, bypassing, or all-provider utilisation measure." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Report published 9 April 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "085bd5d1133bb762d172c225d1107b864d1d270996a353d440877635d54494bb" }, "statement": "ESRI research examines healthcare demand and workforce in primary and acute public hospital care; it is contextual evidence rather than a referral-flow series.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Effects of new residential developments on local healthcare demand and workforce", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.esri.ie/publications/effects-of-new-residential-developments-on-local-healthcare-demand-and-workforce" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. HSE Health Regions. Updated 12 May 2025. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "autonomy", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "Operational responsibility has now moved from the HSE Centre", "institution": "Department of Health, Ireland", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "source_word_anchor": "Operational responsibility has now moved from the HSE Centre", "source_word_count": 9 }, "material_id": "material:b5e73c329546621977825c87", "notes": [ "This formal reform description does not measure region-level decision autonomy or patient-flow effects." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Page updated 12 May 2025; regions commenced March 2024 and management structure changed October 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2025, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "40e16f7eafb7941b25f747791bc203a8cdef9cdbcb3d4c51d9dd3c300acc96f2" }, "statement": "The Department describes six HSE Health Regions intended to align hospital and community services, with operational responsibility moving from the HSE Centre to regions and Integrated Healthcare Areas in October 2024.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland, six HSE Health Regions", "title": "HSE Health Regions", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/hse-health-regions/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Government of Ireland. Health Service Executive Act 2004 (No. 42). Irish Statute Book; 2004. https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "Establishment day and establishment of Executive", "institution": "Irish Statute Book", "locator": { "locator_type": "legislation_section", "source_word_anchor": "Establishment day and establishment of Executive", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:e249f7275633420589d3528b", "notes": [ "Use as formal establishment context only; amendments and present-day delegated arrangements need their own current source." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Act enacted 2004; current-effect questions require consolidated-law checking", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2004, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "8ddbf6e89ca2aaf5a98615513e27dcde273d36076046a5b2dd36289bda2567c2" }, "statement": "The Act establishes the Health Service Executive and sets out its statutory functions; this legal source is retained as formal institutional context.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Health Service Executive Act 2004", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2004/act/42/enacted/en/html" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Health in Ireland: Key Trends - Hospital care. Published 17 May 2026. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/health-in-ireland-key-trends-hospital-care/", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "observed_referral", "patient_flows", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "observed", "excerpt": "Public acute hospital summary statistics, 2015-2024", "institution": "Department of Health, Ireland", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_table", "source_word_anchor": "Public acute hospital summary statistics, 2015-2024", "source_word_count": 6 }, "material_id": "material:d3244312b69550a221f904dc", "notes": [ "The series concerns stated public acute-hospital scope and is not a national referral-completion, bypassing, or all-provider utilisation measure." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Hospital series through 2024, published May 2026", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2026, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "cfe0ace28b47918934db2de402c9288b8cda3534b17fcd86cd6bc60e3e395b17" }, "statement": "The Department publishes a public-acute-hospital series through 2024, including beds, inpatient discharges and emergency-department attendance with stated exclusions and classification caveats.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland, public acute hospitals where stated", "title": "Health in Ireland: Key Trends - Hospital care", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/publications/health-in-ireland-key-trends-hospital-care/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "OECD and European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023. State of Health in the EU. OECD Publishing; 2023. https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "market_structure", "networks", "ownership", "patient_flows", "primary_care", "referral_design", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "organisation of the Irish healthcare system", "institution": "OECD and WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_section_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "organisation of the Irish healthcare system", "source_word_count": 5 }, "material_id": "material:571836dc6eb14aa7e9155724", "notes": [ "This reported synthesis is not a current legal delegation matrix or a provider-level ownership denominator." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Country profile published 15 December 2023", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2023, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "review_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "5853a46e680914664e36c70d49f6c00c95ed0166def77352f7ce92369c19d178" }, "statement": "The profile gives a dated policy-focused overview of Irish health-system organisation, access, performance and mental-health services.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Ireland: Country Health Profile 2023", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/publications/reports/2023/12/ireland-country-health-profile-2023_5b45e4b2/3abe906b-en.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Irish Medical Organisation. Annual Report 2024. 2024. https://www.imo.ie/about-imo/annual-reports/annual-report-2024-1/IMO-Annual-Report-2024-final.pdf", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "facility_data", "hospital_organization", "utilization" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "HSE to blame doctors for long waiting lists", "institution": "Irish Medical Organisation", "locator": { "locator_type": "pdf_page_and_section", "source_word_anchor": "HSE to blame doctors for long waiting lists", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:0348fdf0e884e18a770e4636", "notes": [ "Treat this professional association report as a stated perspective, not an ownership, capacity, utilisation, or referral denominator." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Annual report for 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "grey_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "file_sha256": "0c4fd90260d75c1e77072e24ef5cf8248848ee60a40ec14924f13902d926b60c" }, "statement": "The IMO annual report presents the organisation's capacity and waiting-time concerns; its advocacy position is not treated as an all-provider measure.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Irish Medical Organisation Annual Report 2024", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.imo.ie/about-imo/annual-reports/annual-report-2024-1/IMO-Annual-Report-2024-final.pdf" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Department of Health, Ireland. Primary Care Division. Updated 9 September 2020. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/primary-care-division/", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "market_structure", "primary_care", "referral_design" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "formal", "excerpt": "integrated multidisciplinary care provided by the Health Service Executive", "institution": "Department of Health, Ireland", "locator": { "locator_type": "web_heading_and_paragraph", "source_word_anchor": "integrated multidisciplinary care provided by the Health Service Executive", "source_word_count": 8 }, "material_id": "material:93fea48ea09f370f1f41ad13", "notes": [ "A division description is not evidence of the volume, ownership share, or observed pathway performance of contracted providers." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "Department page updated 9 September 2020", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2020, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "official" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "9c38bd62d623a91b63254e82b64ac90f61e2e77a2b63e88096a51581ba7a4062" }, "statement": "The Department assigns its Primary Care Division policy and implementation-oversight work for primary care, including HSE and contracted-provider services.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Primary Care Division", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-health/organisation-information/primary-care-division/" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "Farsaci L, Fleming P, Almirall-Sanchez A, O'Donoghue C, Thomas S. Understanding the legacies of shocks on health system performance: Exploring Ireland's management of recent crises and its implications for policy. Health Policy. 2024;143:105063. https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/efetch.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38583364&rettype=abstract&retmode=xml", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": "reported", "excerpt": "Irish experience of the 2008 economic crisis and the Covid-19 pandemic", "institution": "Health Policy; PubMed", "locator": { "locator_type": "database_record_and_abstract", "source_word_anchor": "Irish experience of the 2008 economic crisis and the Covid-19 pandemic", "source_word_count": 11 }, "material_id": "material:4236e97bcb0011ec80b3cc50", "notes": [ "The study reports qualitative interpretation of shocks and does not establish present-day legal authority or a provider decision matrix." ], "origin": "country-evidence-improvement-sources", "period": "2008 economic crisis and COVID-19 pandemic; article published 2024", "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2024, "record_kind": "country_improvement_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Country Improvement Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": false, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "research_literature" ], "source_system": null, "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/xml", "response_sha256": "32386588af6e7f8cfde6dcc044f192a37f0491d74e23dc8075be4f73a0e57a6c" }, "statement": "Qualitative research contrasts Irish health-system responses to the 2008 economic crisis and COVID-19; it reports interview-based interpretation rather than a current authority map.", "tags": [], "territory": "Ireland", "title": "Understanding the legacies of shocks on health system performance", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/efetch.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=38583364&rettype=abstract&retmode=xml" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "EU investment grants review. 1999. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "candidate corpus source", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "physical_pdf_page": 2, "source_word_anchor": "Barker Tenenbaum and Woolf Governance and Regulation of Power Pools and System" }, "material_id": "candidate-source:IRL:7ac82fd4304397bb5107", "notes": [ "Public source projection retained as a distinct stage record." ], "origin": "current-public-source-projection", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 1999, "record_kind": "displayed_source_projection", "record_kind_label": "Displayed source projection", "screening": { "previous_visibility": "previously_projected" }, "source_layers": [ "candidate_corpus_page_locator", "grey_literature" ], "source_system": "global_corpus", "source_version": { "file_sha256": "31ba94972300f42af2847d9d5c4020bb079b9799ab008af96c34af2766a131ba", "text_sha256": "4ffb57b65b8c9a13f47c052e0faff0e502769362aeceffc26072b6ba611769aa" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "corpus_excerpt_queue" ], "territory": null, "title": "EU investment grants review", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/599081468761737034/pdf/multi-page.pdf" } ] }, { "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: health system review 2009. 2009. https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "candidate source metadata", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "heading": "Overview", "html_text_block": 4, "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "The European Observatory's Health Systems in Transition HiT reviews are country-based reports", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "candidate-source:IRL:eaa3ac8c7969e140414b", "notes": [ "Public source projection retained as a distinct stage record.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "current-public-source-projection", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2009, "record_kind": "displayed_source_projection", "record_kind_label": "Displayed source projection", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_projected", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "candidate_source_metadata", "review_literature" ], "source_system": "global_health_systems_library_health_system_review", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "982eb0b508ad7284b7af2fc3240a7bfafc3d58e4194533797024aa2c1327df17" }, "statement": null, "tags": [ "curated_review", "grey_library" ], "territory": null, "title": "Ireland: health system review 2009", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "url_status": "available" }, "citation": "European Observatory Health Systems Reviews. Ireland: health system review 2009. European Observatory Health Systems Reviews; 2009. https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/f8214106-48b1-42a9-8e9b-725bf88b04de/content", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "health system review", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "European Observatory Health Systems Reviews", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:0a0812acccfc87819d00b51c", "notes": [ "Catalogue lead displayed in full for source and claim annotation.", "Catalogue geography, title matching, and taxonomy tags require human confirmation.", "No source bytes, exact locator, or atomic claim has been reviewed by the Health Organization registry.", "Grey literature does not by itself establish current formal authority.", "Catalogue ISO3 jurisdiction and an explicit metadata country alias in the title both matched.", "Catalogue document type: health system review.", "Source family: regional_systems.", "Title signal: health_system." ], "origin": "global-grey-source-leads", "period": null, "publication_date": "2009-05-30", "publication_year": 2009, "record_kind": "grey_literature_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Grey Literature Source Lead", "screening": { "candidate_status": "candidate", "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "unreviewed", "status": "candidate", "triage_status": "new" }, "source_layers": [ "regional_systems" ], "source_system": "regional_systems", "source_version": {}, "statement": null, "tags": [ "Catalogue ISO3 jurisdiction and an explicit metadata country alias in the title both matched.", "Catalogue document type: health system review.", "Source family: regional_systems.", "Title signal: health_system.", "catalogue_iso3_match", "explicit_country_alias", "grey_literature", "health_system_organization", "title:health_system", "title_country_alias_match" ], "territory": null, "title": "Ireland: health system review 2009", "urls": [ { "kind": "stable_url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/f8214106-48b1-42a9-8e9b-725bf88b04de/content" }, { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/api/hubs/publications" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/health-systems-reviews" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: health system review 2009. 2009. https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": null, "material_id": "material:96a9a3806efed6b833bbac57", "notes": [ "Citation metadata identifies a country-scoped review lead, but no locally acquired full text was selected for an exact excerpt.", "No country statement is created from title or bibliographic metadata alone." ], "origin": "global-review-evidence-context", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2009, "record_kind": "review_literature_context", "record_kind_label": "Review Literature Context", "screening": { "context_status": "metadata_only", "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review" }, "source_layers": [], "source_system": "global_health_systems_library_health_system_review", "source_version": {}, "statement": null, "tags": [], "territory": null, "title": "Review Literature Context", "urls": [ { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/api/hubs/publications" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/f8214106-48b1-42a9-8e9b-725bf88b04de/content" }, { "kind": "landing", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/health-systems-reviews" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": { "downloaded": false, "extracted": false, "metadata_only": true, "source_bytes_verified": false }, "citation": "Ireland: health system review 2009. 2009. https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": "country_health_system_review", "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": "WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies", "locator": null, "material_id": "material:40130acab4a0a44a7443041f", "notes": [ "Catalogue metadata only. The underlying publication and its edition must be checked before use.", "A Health System Review is contextual evidence, not formal authority for jurisdictional rules.", "National country health-system review in the local Global Health Systems Library.", "National Health System Review selected from the local library by exact document type and title, retaining the newest edition per country." ], "origin": "global-review-source-leads", "period": null, "publication_date": "2009-05-30", "publication_year": 2009, "record_kind": "review_literature_source_lead", "record_kind_label": "Review Literature Source Lead", "screening": { "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review", "triage_status": "new" }, "source_layers": [], "source_system": "Global Health Systems Library", "source_version": {}, "statement": null, "tags": [ "National country health-system review in the local Global Health Systems Library." ], "territory": null, "title": "Ireland: health system review 2009", "urls": [ { "kind": "landing", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009" }, { "kind": "catalogue", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/api/hubs/publications" }, { "kind": "source", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/health-systems-reviews" }, { "kind": "file", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/f8214106-48b1-42a9-8e9b-725bf88b04de/content" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "European Observatory Health Systems Reviews. Ireland: health system review 2009. European Observatory Health Systems Reviews; 2009. https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/f8214106-48b1-42a9-8e9b-725bf88b04de/content", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "actors", "authoritative_review", "government_responsibilities" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "paragraph_index_on_page": 1, "physical_pdf_page": 11, "source_word_anchor": "and emergency department of hospital ADHD HKD Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Hyperkinetic", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:9ed0481173c989f7b667aa77", "notes": [ "Verify the exact bibliographic citation against the original source.", "Confirm that the document applies to the named country and intended territorial scope.", "Confirm document type, issuing institution, authority, and claim-specific suitability.", "Retrieve and hash the exact source version when it is not already verified.", "Check publication date, effective period, currency, and supersession risk.", "Confirm only domains directly supported by the reviewed source.", "Add substantive feedback directly through the text-anchored annotation layer.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-source-triage-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2009, "record_kind": "source_triage_record", "record_kind_label": "Source Triage Record", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "regional_systems" ], "source_system": "regional_systems", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 298, "response_sha256": "8c7b4dac35e11afdea4ae130a2371767a2edd56db6fec20aeede685c0088ce18" }, "statement": null, "tags": [], "territory": null, "title": "Ireland: health system review 2009", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/f8214106-48b1-42a9-8e9b-725bf88b04de/content" } ] }, { "analytical_mapping": {}, "annotation_status": "open", "authors": [], "availability": {}, "citation": "WHO European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies. Ireland: health system review 2009. 2009. https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009", "country_ids": [ "IRL" ], "coverage_domains": [ "decision_rights", "governance", "government_responsibilities", "hospital_organization", "networks", "primary_care", "reform_history" ], "display_status": "shown_in_full", "document_type": null, "evidence_mode": null, "excerpt": null, "institution": null, "locator": { "heading": "Overview", "html_text_block": 4, "locator_type": "html_text_anchor", "source_word_anchor": "The European Observatory's Health Systems in Transition HiT reviews are country-based reports", "source_word_count": 12 }, "material_id": "material:e5c6fc1e07348cb4f280012f", "notes": [ "Verify the exact bibliographic citation against the original source.", "Confirm that the document applies to the named country and intended territorial scope.", "Confirm document type, issuing institution, authority, and claim-specific suitability.", "Retrieve and hash the exact source version when it is not already verified.", "Check publication date, effective period, currency, and supersession risk.", "Confirm only domains directly supported by the reviewed source.", "Add substantive feedback directly through the text-anchored annotation layer.", "Immutable source-version metadata was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition.", "A recoverable source locator was retrieved from this exact public source URL in the single-country score-improvement acquisition." ], "origin": "global-source-triage-queue", "period": null, "publication_date": null, "publication_year": 2009, "record_kind": "source_triage_record", "record_kind_label": "Source Triage Record", "screening": { "page_locator_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true, "previous_boundary_detected": true, "previous_visibility": "previously_not_projected", "review_status": "needs_review", "source_version_linked_from_country_score_acquisition": true }, "source_layers": [ "global_health_systems_library_health_system_review" ], "source_system": "global_health_systems_library_health_system_review", "source_version": { "detected_media_type": "text/html", "response_sha256": "982eb0b508ad7284b7af2fc3240a7bfafc3d58e4194533797024aa2c1327df17" }, "statement": null, "tags": [], "territory": null, "title": "Ireland: health system review 2009", "urls": [ { "kind": "url", "source": "not supplied", "url": "https://eurohealthobservatory.who.int/publications/i/ireland-health-system-review-2009" } ] } ] }